The leaking shelf
Source: an original fiction extract.
Sima’s uncle had left three instructions beside the till. Check every banknote. Keep the back door locked. Do not let Mrs Baines’s parcel out of sight. The parcel sat on the shelf behind Sima, wrapped in brown paper and tied with red string. Each time the shop door opened, she glanced back to make sure it was still there.
By five o’clock, rain was beating against the windows. Water had begun to gather in one corner of the ceiling, directly above the newspaper stand. Sima placed a bucket beneath it while four customers waited at the till. Her uncle had trusted her to manage the shop alone for one afternoon, and she was determined that he would find everything exactly as he had left it.
Eli came in with rain shining on his hair. He bought a carton of milk and pointed towards the ceiling behind Sima. “There’s water running along that shelf,” he said. Sima told him she already knew about the leak. A customer asked for a refund, another wanted change for the parking meter, and the telephone began ringing in the room at the back. For several minutes, Sima faced nothing but hands, coins and receipts.
When the queue had gone, Mrs Baines’s parcel was missing.
Eli was still beside the stockroom curtain. A flat piece of brown cardboard lay near his shoes, and his sleeves were wet to the elbows. Sima stepped between him and the door.
“Put it back,” she said.
Eli stared at her. “I did. I was trying to—”
“Open your bag.”
Two customers who had been examining tins turned to watch. Eli slowly unfastened his rucksack and held it open. It contained a library book, a football shirt and the carton of milk. His face had become a fierce, embarrassed red.
“It’s behind the flour sacks,” he said.
Sima pushed through the curtain. The parcel was on the floor beneath a plastic sheet, perfectly dry. Through the doorway, she could see water striking the shelf where it had been: one heavy drop, then another. The brown cardboard by Eli’s feet was the collapsed tray that had held the morning’s oranges.
“You should have told me you were moving it,” Sima said.
“I tried.”
He pulled the zip across his bag. The watching customers suddenly found the tins interesting again.
Mrs Baines arrived before Eli had left. When she saw the dry parcel and the water spreading across the empty shelf, she thanked Sima for taking care of it. Sima looked towards Eli.
“He moved it,” she said. “It would have been ruined otherwise.”
Outside, under the shop’s narrow awning, Sima caught up with him. She began by saying that the parcel had disappeared and that he had been standing near the stockroom. The explanation sounded reasonable until she heard herself giving it.
“I didn’t listen,” she said instead. “I’m sorry.”
Eli nodded, but he did not smile. He walked away through the rain with his rucksack held close against his back. When Sima returned to the empty shop, the bucket was filling steadily. Each drop seemed louder than the one before it.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Sima’s fear of making a mistake causes her to treat Eli as guilty before she knows what has happened. The writer makes her panic understandable, but does not excuse her judgement.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.