The upper aviary
Source: an original fiction extract.
The wind began testing the upper aviary shortly after four, pressing its wire roof down and releasing it with a shudder. Sana heard each movement from the food store below. She had reported the loose roof panel twice that week, but Ms Harker had examined it from the path and said the maintenance team would come on Monday.
Before leaving to check the lower enclosures, Ms Harker had given Sana one instruction: if the weather worsened, she must stay out of the upper aviary. Its inner catch sometimes jammed, and frightened birds crowded any open door. Sana had nodded. Now she tried the radio. Static answered, followed by three broken words she could not understand. She called again and received nothing.
A sharp metallic crack sounded above her. Sana ran outside. One corner of the roof panel was lifting clear of its frame, and beneath it the birds circled in a confusion of wings. The emergency canvas screen could cover the damaged section, but its red release cord was inside the aviary. Sana knew this because Ms Harker had demonstrated it during her first week. She also remembered Ms Harker saying, “Monday will be soon enough.” For an instant, the thought of proving that it had not been soon enough brought Sana a satisfaction so bright that she was ashamed of it.
Another gust raised the panel. Sana imagined returning with Ms Harker to an empty enclosure. She unlocked the outer door and stepped into the narrow entrance lobby. The wind pulled at the door behind her. She dragged it shut until it touched the frame, but did not stop to test the latch. At the inner door, the catch resisted once and then released.
Noise and feathers filled the air. Sana kept her head down and moved towards the red cord. The birds swept around her, changing direction together whenever the roof struck its frame. She pulled the cord. Nothing happened. She wrapped it around both hands and leaned backwards until the canvas screen dropped across the damaged corner. Its metal edge struck the wall, and the loose panel disappeared behind it. The next gust made the screen bulge, but it held.
Sana turned towards the entrance. The outer door was standing open. A small brown bird shot through the lobby and vanished into the rain before she could close it. She secured the latch and remained with her back against the door, counting the birds as they settled. She counted again. One was missing.
Ms Harker arrived carrying a torch and a coil of rope. She looked first at the screen, then at Sana. “You stopped the panel tearing away,” she said. After checking the birds, she added, “You also entered alone.”
Sana explained that the radio had failed and that there had been no time to wait. Both statements were true. When Ms Harker asked whether the wind had forced the outer door open, Sana looked at the latch. There was no broken metal, no splintered wood: only a clean mechanism waiting to be pressed into place.
“I pulled the door closed,” Sana said. “I didn’t check it.”
In the office, Ms Harker placed an incident form between them. Under Damage prevented, Sana wrote that the emergency screen had secured the roof. Under Consequences, she wrote that one bird was missing because she had failed to check the outer latch. The two sentences occupied equal spaces on the page.
Sana returned at first light. The repaired screen was stretched firmly above eleven birds, while one line on the counting board remained empty. Ms Harker handed her a pair of binoculars and told her to begin searching beside the orchard wall. As Sana crossed the yard, the wind rose again. Behind her, the screen snapped tight and held.
A student who read the whole source said:
“Initially, Sana’s decision seems courageous and necessary. However, the final part makes us question her motives and whether the result can really be called a success.”
Evaluate this view of the source. Support your response with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.