The last reading
Source: an original fiction extract.
The gatehouse stood where the millpond narrowed into the river, a square brick room with windows on three sides. Marek had spent school holidays there while his father recorded water levels in a ruled book and adjusted the sluice gates by hand. Now the books filled two metal cupboards, and the new control panel occupied most of the wall.
This was the final evening before the gates were placed under remote control. On Monday, readings would be sent directly to an office twelve miles away. Marek had been taken on as a temporary assistant during the changeover, partly because he already knew the building and partly, he suspected, because everyone remembered his father.
The installation engineers had left at four. As they carried out their cases, one of them had glanced at the old cupboards and said that people used to watch dials which were perfectly capable of watching themselves. Marek had smiled as if the remark did not matter.
At six minutes past six, the digital display showed a water level of forty-one centimetres. Marek looked through the window at the painted gauge fixed to the wall outside. The water had reached forty-seven. Above the telephone, the operating instructions said that a difference of more than five centimetres must be reported immediately. An amber fault symbol flashed once on the panel and disappeared.
Marek picked up the telephone, then put it down. If he reported a single flash, the engineers would say the old gauge was inaccurate. If he waited until the difference increased, there would be proof that a person in the gatehouse could notice what the panel had missed. He wrote “18:06 — screen 41, wall 47” in the small notebook that had belonged to his father. Waiting for one more reading, he told himself, was not the same as hiding anything.
Rain struck the windows with a sound like handfuls of gravel. The radio clicked, and Rina’s voice came from the control office. She reminded him that the rowing club downstream was clearing its equipment from the landing stage. The automatic system was programmed to open the first gate gradually if the recorded level reached fifty centimetres.
“Anything unusual there?” she asked.
Marek looked at the dark line of water outside. “No. Forty-one and steady.”
Once the radio was silent, the words seemed to remain in the room. He went outside with a torch. The painted gauge now showed fifty-one centimetres, while the panel inside still showed forty-three. He could have reported the difference then. Instead, he opened the cabinet beneath the display and pressed each wire firmly into its connection. His father had often repaired loose contacts without calling anyone.
On the desk, the old notebook lay open. Its columns were neat and narrow. There were no comments about weather, engineers or the unfairness of new machines. Marek remembered his father saying that a reading had to describe the water, not the person taking it. He turned the notebook face down.
The radio sounded again. This time Rina did not wait for him to answer. The rowing club’s caretaker had reported water covering the lowest step of the landing stage. Because the control panel was recording a lower level, the automatic gate had not opened. Releasing the water now would have to be managed carefully so that the level downstream did not rise too quickly.
Rina told Marek to sound the warning siren and check that the riverside path was clear. Through the rain, he saw a man carrying two oars from the landing stage. The man stopped when the siren began and returned to the clubhouse. Marek’s hand shook as he operated the manual controls in the sequence Rina gave him. The first gate lifted a few centimetres. Brown water pushed beneath it, carrying leaves and a football into the river.
When the level had begun to fall, Rina asked when Marek had first noticed the difference.
“Six minutes past six,” he said.
She looked at the official log when she arrived at the gatehouse. The page for that evening was blank. Marek showed her his father’s notebook and explained that he had wanted clear evidence before the engineers dismissed the old gauge.
“You had evidence,” Rina said. “You put it somewhere no one else could use it.”
While she checked the control panel, Marek opened the notebook at random. Years earlier, his father had written a level of sixty-two centimetres, crossed it out and replaced it with twenty-six. Beside the correction were the words: “Wrong figure reported. Control office informed, 18:12.” Marek read the sentence twice.
The remote system would still begin operating on Monday. Rina said the delayed report would be included in her account of the fault. She also said that the system would need monthly checks against the painted gauge and that Marek could apply to join the inspection team, although tonight’s decisions would be considered.
Before leaving, Marek completed the final page of the gatehouse log. He recorded the conflicting readings, the manual release and the time at which the path had been cleared. After a pause, he added that he had delayed reporting the fault. He returned his father’s notebook to the cupboard rather than putting it in his pocket. Outside, the rain was easing, but water continued to pass beneath the gate.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Marek delays reporting the faulty reading mainly because he wants to defend his father’s way of working. The writer values his loyalty, but presents his dishonesty as the greater danger and refuses to turn his eventual confession into heroism.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.