The reserve speaker
Source: an original fiction extract.
By lunchtime, the school hall had been rearranged for the debate. Rows of chairs faced a single table and a wooden lectern. Amira was the reserve speaker, although Mr Hales had assured her that she would only need to keep time and pass Daniel his prompt cards. She liked those tasks. They had clear edges: start the clock, stop the clock, hold up the warning card. None of them required her to face an audience.
Ten minutes before the debate, Daniel arrived with his scarf pulled over his mouth. When he tried to speak, only a rough whisper came out. Mr Hales gave him water and asked him to rest, but the first pupils were already entering the hall. Their voices spread through the room, gathering into a steady hum. Amira placed Daniel’s cards in a neat pile and pressed both palms on top of them, as if that could keep the afternoon in its proper order.
When Mr Hales asked whether she could take Daniel’s place, Amira looked past him at the green fire-exit sign. She could say no. Nobody had expected her to prepare the whole speech. ‘I could read the opening,’ she said at last. As she stood, her knee struck the underside of the table. The prompt cards slid apart, and she had to gather them while the opposing team watched. She felt each second opening around her.
At the lectern, her first ‘Good afternoon’ was so quiet that Mr Hales leaned forwards. Heat rushed into her face. She gripped the sides of the lectern and began again. This time, the words reached the back row. For the first minute, she read directly from Daniel’s cards. Then she came to an example she recognised from their own school and looked up to explain it. The hall had not changed: the chairs were still full and dozens of eyes were still fixed on her. Yet the next sentence arrived without her having to search for it.
A speaker from the other team stood to challenge her argument. Amira’s fingers tightened around the final card. She could return to her seat and let Mr Hales answer. Instead, she admitted that the other speaker had made a fair point before explaining why she still disagreed. Her voice shook on one word, but she finished the sentence. When she sat down, the card in her hand had been bent into a narrow curve. Daniel whispered, ‘How did you manage that?’ Amira slowly flattened the card against the table. ‘I didn’t stop being scared,’ she said. ‘I just didn’t sit down.’
Read the final three paragraphs, beginning with ‘When Mr Hales asked’.
A student thinks that Amira’s courage comes from acting even though she remains afraid. Evaluate this view of Amira’s behaviour and the way the writer shapes the reader’s response to her.
In your answer, you may consider:
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.