The paper whale
Source: an original fiction extract.
At four o’clock, the paper whale hung from the roof of the community hall. Its pale body stretched above three rows of folding chairs, supported by a frame of thin canes and the ropes that would be used to carry it through the streets. When the lights inside it were switched on, blue circles appeared along its sides like windows into deep water.
Mira stood beneath its head, holding the front carrying pole. Mrs Kaye had given her that position because she had attended every workshop and had never arrived late. The pole was heavier than Mira had expected, but she kept it level while the other volunteers practised turning. When Mrs Kaye told everyone to rest, Mira lowered it carefully onto two tables.
The procession was due to begin in an hour. Volunteers hurried between the hall and the yard, collecting batteries, tape and boxes of paper stars. Mrs Kaye reminded them twice to keep the side door shut because the wind was strengthening. Each time someone opened it, the whale stirred above the tables.
Mira was sent to fetch a bundle of spare rope. The quickest route was through the side door, but it swung closed before she could carry the bundle back. She looked at the long corridor leading to the main entrance, then wedged an empty paint tin beneath the door. She would remove it as soon as she returned.
In the store room, the ropes had become tangled around a chair leg. By the time Mira freed them, she could hear people shouting in the hall. She ran back. The door was wide open. A gust had lifted the whale’s head and twisted it towards the wall. One of its fins struck the corner of a table. There was a dry snapping sound, and a crease opened across the painted paper.
Tariq, the youngest volunteer, stood beside the paint tin. He had been told earlier not to touch the carrying equipment. Mrs Kaye looked first at him and then at the open door.
‘What happened?’ she asked.
Mira placed the ropes on the floor. ‘The wind caught it.’
This was true, but the words felt carefully arranged. Tariq said that he had not opened the door. Mrs Kaye asked why the tin was there. He stared at it as if it had appeared for the purpose of accusing him. Around them, the other volunteers had stopped moving.
Mira imagined losing her place beneath the whale’s head. She imagined Mrs Kaye’s disappointment, which seemed worse than anger. For a moment, she hoped the silence would end without requiring anything from her.
Then Tariq began to explain where he had been, speaking faster as Mrs Kaye’s expression became less patient.
‘I put the tin there,’ Mira said.
Nobody answered immediately. Mira explained about the rope and the long corridor. As she spoke, the reasons that had seemed sensible a few minutes earlier became small and untidy. Mrs Kaye did not tell her that it did not matter.
‘Thank you for saying so,’ she said at last. ‘Now help me repair it.’
Mira spent the next forty minutes holding the broken fin while Mrs Kaye bound the cane and covered the tear with another layer of paper. Tariq took Mira’s position at the front. When the whale was lifted, its repaired fin dipped slightly lower than the other one.
The procession left after sunset. From inside the paper body, the lamps made the new patch shine more brightly than the original surface. Mira walked beside the final carrying pole with the tape and scissors. At the corner of the square, a gust pushed against the whale. The carriers slowed, and Mira reached for the loose edge of the repair. Above her hand, the crease remained visible, a thin dark line beneath the blue light.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “The story suggests that honesty matters most when telling the truth has a personal cost and cannot undo the harm already caused.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.