The low field
Source: an original fiction extract.
Beyond the campsite, a grey line of cloud rested on the hills. Mr Holt gave each group a canvas shelter, a bundle of poles and a sheet of instructions. They had forty minutes before the rain reached the field.
Nia’s group looked at her. Her name was written beside the word leader on Mr Holt’s list, and she had spent the coach journey imagining this moment. She tucked the instructions beneath her arm and pointed towards a hollow near the water tap.
‘We’ll build there. Ellis, take the poles. Sam, sort the ropes. Rowan, bring the canvas.’
Rowan pressed his boot into the ground. When he lifted it, water shone in the mark.
‘There’s a higher place beside the stone wall,’ he said.
Nia looked towards it. The wall was only fifty metres away, but carrying the equipment there would use time. ‘This is closer,’ she said. ‘If we stop to discuss everything, the rain will arrive first.’
She unfolded the canvas and began calling out instructions. Sam tried to ask which ropes were needed, but Nia was busy forcing two poles together. Ellis held one end of the shelter while Rowan stood with the folded instructions that had slipped from beneath Nia’s arm.
‘It says the shorter poles go across the top,’ he said.
‘I know what I’m doing.’ Nia took the paper from him without reading it.
The first drops landed heavily enough to leave dark circles on the canvas. Nia ordered Ellis to pull harder. The shelter rose, leaned towards the tap and then collapsed over Sam. For several seconds, the canvas moved as he tried to find the opening.
Ellis laughed, but Nia did not. She blamed the soft ground and told everyone to begin again. When she pushed the first peg back into the soil, it slid sideways beneath her hand.
‘The wall would block some of the wind,’ Rowan said. He spoke quietly, as if expecting his words to be refused before he had finished them. ‘And the ground there is firmer. I put up one of these shelters at my youth club last month.’
Nia looked at the others. Rain was running from Sam’s hair onto his glasses. Ellis still held a pole in each hand, waiting to be told which one mattered. The word leader on Mr Holt’s list no longer felt like a prize. It felt like a question she had answered too quickly.
‘Show us,’ she said to Rowan.
They carried the equipment to the wall. This time, Nia opened the instructions on the grass and held the corners down with stones. Rowan explained how the poles fitted together, but he did not take over. Nia asked Ellis to assemble the frame and Sam to thread the ropes through the canvas. When Sam suggested fastening one side before lifting the other, Nia nodded.
The rain strengthened. Their hands slipped on the wet poles, and twice they had to undo work they had rushed. Nia stopped giving orders across the whole group. Instead, she moved between them, holding a joint steady for Ellis and checking the instructions with Rowan. When the shelter finally stood, one side sagged and the entrance faced slightly away from the path, but all four of them could fit beneath it.
Mr Holt arrived in a waterproof coat. He inspected the ropes and pressed one of the pegs with his foot.
‘Who led this group?’ he asked.
Nia glanced at Rowan. Mud covered the knees of his trousers, and he was tightening the final rope.
‘We built it together,’ she said. ‘Rowan found the right place.’
That night, the rain tapped steadily against the canvas. One corner began to flap in the wind. Nia woke and reached towards the rope, then stopped. Rowan was already awake on the other side of the shelter.
‘Does that need tightening?’ she whispered.
He listened for a moment before answering.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “The story suggests that effective leadership depends on recognising other people’s knowledge, rather than simply giving the quickest or loudest instructions.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.