The final rebuttal
Source: an original fiction extract.
The brass cup stood at the edge of the stage, reflecting the hall in a curved, golden blur. Amara had looked at it during every practice for twelve Saturdays. Beside her, Leila arranged their notes in the order they had agreed: opening claim, three challenges, final sentence. They had written that sentence together, testing each word until neither of them could remember who had suggested it first.
Their opponents spoke first. Yusuf began confidently, but halfway through his argument he glanced towards the audience and lost his place. He searched his cards, turning one over and then back again. Somebody laughed near the rear doors. The red digits on the competition clock continued to fall.
Amara knew what Yusuf had been about to say. She had found the same evidence while preparing and had spent an evening working out how to answer it. Without that point, his argument had a wide, obvious gap. Leila noticed it too. She drew a box around one line in their notes and wrote, in letters large enough for Amara to see, USE THE GAP.
When their rebuttal began, Amara stood at the lectern. For the first thirty seconds, she followed the plan. Then she saw Yusuf staring at the card he had failed to read. The laughter had stopped, but he was still holding the card with both hands, as if the paper might escape.
“Before I challenge the previous speaker,” Amara said, “I think his final point deserves to be heard properly.”
She explained the argument Yusuf had been trying to make. She did not weaken it. She included the evidence, the example and even the question that made it difficult to answer. A murmur moved through the audience. Across the table, Yusuf looked up.
Leila pushed a card towards the lectern. STOP, it said now. Amara placed her hand over the card and continued. She answered Yusuf’s argument carefully, but the warning bell sounded before she reached their final sentence. When the second bell rang, she was still speaking. The chair thanked her and asked her to sit down.
In the corridor, while the judges made their decision, Leila closed the folder.
“You answered the speech he didn’t give,” she said.
“It was the argument he meant to give.”
“Perhaps. But you used our time to give it for him.” Leila tucked the folder under her arm. “We were a team before you decided what was fair.”
The judges awarded the cup to Yusuf’s team by one mark. The chief judge praised Amara for engaging with the strongest possible version of an opposing argument. Then she explained that Amara’s team had lost marks for exceeding the time limit and failing to complete its conclusion.
Yusuf found Amara as the audience was leaving. He thanked her quietly and said he wished he had managed to make the point himself. Amara watched his team carry the cup away. She was pleased that he no longer looked ashamed, but the pleasure did not remove the hard weight of losing.
Outside, Leila was waiting beneath the entrance canopy. Rain rattled against the pavement between them. After a moment, she held out the folder.
“Next time,” she said, “you ask me first.”
Amara took it. Their unused final sentence was still on top, underlined twice.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Amara’s decision is admirable because she refuses to take advantage of Yusuf’s mistake, but the writer also shows that she lets her own sense of fairness matter more than Leila’s.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.