The altered cue
Imogen had spent most of the term in the school theatre, learning the lighting desk from Mr Vale. She knew the cues for the final scene by heart: a slow fade, a pause, then a narrow white beam on the paper moon. The effect was simple, but the audience usually fell quiet when it appeared. Imogen wanted to make it more striking. During a rehearsal, she altered the cue so that the whole stage would go dark at once. She did not ask Mr Vale. She told herself she would change it back if it failed.
It failed on the night of the performance. The sudden darkness came before the last line. When the lights returned, the paper moon was still being carried across the stage, and several people in the audience laughed. The actors finished the scene, but Imogen stayed at the desk with both hands flat on its edge. Mr Vale did not speak to her until the audience had left. Then he asked what she had changed. Imogen described the new cue and admitted she had made it without permission.
The next afternoon, Mr Vale gathered the cast and crew in the theatre. He asked Imogen to explain the change herself. She began by saying she had wanted the moon to have more impact, then stopped when she saw the actors looking at her. She said she had made the scene harder for them and that she should have asked first. One actor said the early blackout had made it impossible to finish the line naturally. Another said the sudden return of the lights had made the paper moon look like a joke. Imogen listened without interrupting.
Mr Vale said the original cue would be used for the next performance. Imogen would not operate the lighting desk that evening, but he asked her to help the crew rebuild the moon's shadow screen, which had been taken down after the previous night's show. She had expected to be sent home. Instead, she spent an hour measuring and cutting fresh paper while the actors rehearsed. When the screen was ready, they tested the old cue together. The moon appeared cleanly, and nobody laughed. Mr Vale gave Imogen the marked cue sheet to return to the folder.
Before the doors opened, Imogen noticed, on the back of the sheet, the small sketch she had made of her dramatic blackout. She could have torn it off, but she folded the page so the sketch was hidden and put it away. From the back row, she watched the scene begin. The actors reached the final line; then the stage faded, and the moon appeared in its beam. This time, the silence lasted until the scene was over. Imogen did not go to the lighting desk. She stayed beside the crew, holding the spare roll of paper.
Focus on the final three paragraphs, from ‘The next afternoon’ to the end.
A reader said: ‘Mr Vale’s response is fair because it makes Imogen face the consequences of her choice while giving her a chance to help put things right.’
To what extent do you agree and/or disagree? Evaluate Mr Vale’s response and its effect on Imogen, using evidence and analysis of the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.