The fork in the path
Source: an original fiction extract.
Cerys had been given the route card because she was the only person who had arrived early. By the time the walking group reached the woods, rain had softened its corners and blurred two of the instructions into blue clouds. She folded the card so that the damaged section was hidden beneath her thumb. Behind her, six pairs of boots pressed dark shapes into the mud.
At first, leading felt simple. When the path became slippery, Cerys told everyone to leave more space. When Rowan caught his foot beneath a root, she stopped the group and waited until he was steady. Her voice sounded calm even to her. At each marker post, the others looked towards her, and she enjoyed being ready with an answer before anyone had finished asking the question.
The path divided beside a fallen oak. One branch climbed between the trees; the other dipped towards the sound of water. Cerys examined the route card. The words after fallen oak had dissolved into a pale stain. Malik said he remembered the stream from the outward journey and thought they should take the lower path. ‘The return route is different,’ Cerys replied. She chose the higher branch so quickly that the group followed before he could answer.
Ten minutes later, the path narrowed and ended at a fence. Beyond it stood a field they had not seen before. Cerys announced that there must be another opening and walked along the fence, although brambles repeatedly caught her coat. Nobody spoke. When they passed a glove hanging from a thorn for the second time, Rowan asked whether they were lost. Cerys looked down at the card. Rainwater had reached the final instruction, and a drop slid slowly across the printed word road.
‘I can’t read it,’ she said. The admission was quieter than her earlier instructions, but the silence around her changed. Malik came to stand beside her rather than behind. He remembered crossing the stream near a stone step; Rowan had noticed a marker with a white stripe; another walker could hear traffic beyond the lower trees. They returned to the fallen oak and compared what each person remembered. Cerys asked Malik to choose the path towards the stream.
When the group reached the road, nobody cheered, but shoulders loosened and conversation returned. Cerys unfolded the route card completely and held it where everyone could see the spreading ink. On the walk back, she no longer hurried to answer first. She moved to the rear, counted the group at every turning and asked Rowan to point out the white markers. At the final gate, Malik offered the route card back to her. Cerys shook her head. ‘Keep it open,’ she said. ‘We’ll read it together.’
Consider the source as a whole. One reader commented: “Cerys’s confidence helps the group at first, but the writer suggests that honesty, rather than certainty, finally makes her an effective leader.” Evaluate this view. Refer closely to the text and consider the writer’s methods in your response.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.