The red flare
Source: an original fiction extract.
The fog had erased the harbour before the engine stopped. One moment, Nadiya could see the yellow wall behind them; the next, there was only the small survey boat, six bottles of seawater in a crate and her aunt Leila's hand resting on the silent controls.
Leila checked the compass and unfolded the chart. She had worked in the harbour for eighteen years and moved without hurry. "No emergency," she said. "The current is carrying us south, away from Carrick Shoal. We have twenty minutes before it turns." She called the harbour office on the radio. A voice broke into pieces beneath the crackle and then vanished. Leila frowned, but said the main aerial often misbehaved in damp weather. There was a spare below deck.
The depth display changed from fourteen metres to eleven. Then it showed eight. Nadiya watched until it fell to six. Leila tapped the screen with one finger. "That sensor has been unreliable all week." She lifted the engine cover and asked for the tool roll.
Somewhere to their left, a buoy bell sounded once. According to the chart, the Carrick bell stood beside the shoal. Nadiya could not see it, but she could see something broad and black lifting through the fog ahead. Leila said that sound travelled strangely in fog and that the shape might be floating rubbish. She bent further into the engine compartment.
Nadiya opened the emergency locker and took out a red flare.
Leila straightened. "Put that back. A red flare means grave and immediate danger. Give me two minutes to connect the spare aerial."
The depth display flickered between six and five. The black shape appeared again, nearer now. Nadiya pulled the cord.
Red light burst above them, turning the fog into a glowing wall. For a second, Leila's face seemed carved from the same hard colour. Then the flare climbed out of sight.
A rescue boat arrived six minutes later. Its wash rolled the black shape over, revealing a sheet of tarpaulin tangled around a wooden pallet. The depth display jumped from five metres to nineteen. The rescue coxswain checked his screen and said that they were seven hundred metres east of Carrick Shoal and drifting towards open water.
"So there was no immediate danger," Leila said.
The coxswain looked at the dead engine and the useless radio. "Not then. Dead engines and fog have a way of becoming danger."
At the harbour office, a mechanic reported what he had found. A cooling hose had split, so the engine should not have been run. The main radio call had never transmitted. However, the depth sensor had a corroded connection, and the spare aerial worked on its first test. Leila had been right about their position and the current.
A blank incident form lay between Leila and Nadiya. Under Describe the circumstances and action taken, Nadiya wrote: Engine disabled. Main radio failed. Depth reduced from fourteen metres to five. Unidentified obstruction sighted. Situation worsening, so distress flare fired.
She did not mention the faulty sensor, the tarpaulin or the spare aerial. Under Instructions given before the flare, she wrote: Captain attempting repair.
Leila read the sentence over her shoulder. "That is true," she said, "and not the truth."
Nadiya knew that the word WAIT would fit in the space that remained. She capped the pen.
A student said: “Nadiya's decision to fire the flare is responsible because Leila underestimates the danger. By the end, however, the writer makes Nadiya's account of her decision less trustworthy than the decision itself.” Evaluate how far you agree. In your answer, evaluate how the contrasting evidence in the harbour office changes your judgement. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer's methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.