The chair in pieces
Source: an original fiction extract.
On the first morning of the restoration workshop, Malik chose the worst chair in the room. Its seat sagged, one of its back rails moved when he touched it, and the wooden arms were crowded with scratches. Initials had been cut into one side, beneath a five-pointed star. Across the workshop stood a finished cabinet whose polished doors reflected the windows. Malik imagined the chair beside it: straight, shining and rescued from every sign of its previous life.
The chair belonged to the reading room at the community centre. It was due to return there at the end of the week. Mrs Harcourt, who ran the workshop, asked Malik to make a written record before he began. He listed the loose rail, the torn seat and the marked arms under the heading ‘damage’. Then he tightened the joints and replaced the worn fabric. Those repairs were slow and awkward, but the chair became firm beneath his hands. The scratches remained. On Wednesday, Malik took a fresh sheet of sandpaper and began on the arm with the initials. He worked until the points of the star disappeared and the first letter became a pale curve.
A woman visiting the workshop stopped beside him. She introduced herself as Mrs Venn and asked whether the chair had come from the reading room. Malik said it had, although it would look very different when he had finished. Mrs Venn placed two fingers over the half-erased letter. She explained that her brother had carved the initials while working at the centre as a teenager. He had later spent years repairing books there. After he died, she sometimes chose this chair because the star was still under her hand. She smiled at Malik’s expression and added that her brother would not have thanked anyone for leaving the chair unsafe. ‘A loose chair is no memorial,’ she said.
When Mrs Venn had gone, Malik put the sandpaper away. He was angry with her for arriving too late, then with Mrs Harcourt for not warning him, and finally with himself for deciding that every mark meant the same thing. Mrs Harcourt examined the chair without offering to rescue him from the decision. Malik could not restore the missing points of the star without inventing lines that had not survived. Instead, he softened the pale patch so that it did not look freshly wounded. He cleaned the remaining grooves and left the smaller scratches untouched. Under the seat, where an earlier repair had split, he fitted a neat new support.
On Friday morning, as Malik prepared the chair for its return, Mrs Harcourt noticed that the carved arm shifted under pressure. A split ran from its underside towards the star. Replacing the arm would make the job quicker, but it would remove the initials altogether. Malik set the chair aside rather than send it back in that state. He cut a narrow strip of wood to fit beneath the split and fixed it in place, checking the arm again before he was satisfied. The repair took most of the morning. When Mrs Venn came to collect the chair, she rested her hand on the arm and leaned on it. It held. Malik carried the chair into the reading room, where Mrs Venn placed it beside the low shelf.
Consider the whole source. A student said: “The writer shows that Malik’s skill was never the problem. What he has to learn is that some marks on an old chair are worth keeping, and his final repair proves that he has learnt it.”
Evaluate this view. Support your response with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.