The paper moon
By nine o’clock, the town hall belonged to Ruth. The tables had been pushed against the walls, leaving the floor clear for the enormous paper moon she was building for the winter play. She had bent the bamboo frame herself and pasted each white panel until the shape appeared to float above its wooden supports. Whenever somebody offered to stay and help, Ruth found them a coat, thanked them and watched them leave.
Caleb arrived while she was mixing the last bowl of paste. Rain shone on his shoulders. He placed his keys on the nearest table as if he still knew where everything belonged. ‘Mum said you’d be here,’ he explained. Ruth continued stirring. Her brother had missed the previous two winter plays and most of the year between them. ‘You’re late,’ she said, although she had not asked him to come.
Before Caleb could answer, the fire door swung open behind him. A gust travelled across the hall, lifting the moon from its supports. Ruth caught one edge, but the bamboo hoop twisted beyond her reach. There was a dry crack. Caleb seized the opposite side before it struck the floor. For several seconds they stood beneath the sagging paper, each holding a half of the broken frame. ‘Let go,’ Ruth said. Caleb looked at the distance between her hands and shook his head.
For a moment, Ruth tightened her grip until the bamboo pressed a red line across her palm. Then she moved one hand towards him. ‘Keep that side level,’ she said. They lowered the moon together and knelt beside the split. Their first attempt pulled the paper crooked; their second loosened as soon as they lifted it. Ruth gave instructions in short, hard sentences, but she did not take the cord away from him. When Caleb suggested crossing the knot twice, she held the frame steady while he tried. ‘That might carry it,’ she said. The word ‘might’ seemed to remain between them.
At dawn, they raised the moon again. A pale crease ran across its surface, and the repaired hoop bent slightly where Caleb’s knot held it. He began to apologise, but Ruth asked him to take the heavier end. As they carried it towards the stage, she shortened her steps to match his. In the wings, the stage crew arriving for the morning rehearsal turned to look. Ruth felt Caleb’s side of the frame dip and tightened her hands, ready to take the full weight. It rose again before she needed to. She kept walking. The moon was damaged, and everyone would see it, but it moved onto the stage between them.
Focus on the final two paragraphs, from ‘For a moment, Ruth’ to the end.
A reader said: ‘Ruth begins to trust Caleb again, but the writer presents this as hesitant and painful rather than a complete reconciliation.’
To what extent do you agree and/or disagree? Evaluate how the writer presents Ruth’s reactions and decisions, using evidence and analysis of the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.