The house cup
Source: an original fiction extract.
Amir and Dev had been asked to carry the house cup from the display cabinet to the assembly hall. It was taller than Amir's forearm, with two silver handles and the names of winning teams engraved around its wooden base. Dev held it above his head as they crossed the empty corridor.
“Practising for Saturday,” he said. The football team was choosing its new captain after Saturday's match. Dev turned towards an imaginary crowd, caught his sleeve on a door handle and lost his grip. The cup struck the floor. Its base split with a sound like a branch snapping, and one of the engraved plates slid beneath a radiator.
For a moment, neither boy moved. Then Dev retrieved the plate and pushed it into Amir's hand. “Put that in your pocket. I'll bring some glue tomorrow.”
Amir stared at the crack. “They'll notice.”
“Only if somebody points it out.” Dev placed the cup on a table with the damaged side facing the wall. When Amir still hesitated, Dev added, “You were carrying it too.” Amir had not been touching it when it fell, but he turned the cup a little further towards the wall. The loose plate felt unexpectedly heavy in his pocket.
The next morning, the cup was back in the cabinet. Mrs Khan, the caretaker, stood beside it while a teacher examined the broken base. She said she might have knocked it while polishing the shelf, although she could not remember doing so. The teacher asked her to check whether anything else had been damaged. Across the corridor, Dev fixed his attention on a poster. Amir felt heat rise above his collar, but the bell rang and everyone moved towards the hall.
During assembly, the headteacher placed the damaged cup on the stage. A whisper travelled along Amir's row that Mrs Khan had dropped it. The story became more certain each time it was repeated. Amir looked at Dev, but Dev leaned closer and murmured, “It was an accident. Don't ruin everything over an accident.”
The headteacher asked anyone with information to speak to her afterwards. Amir imagined waiting until the hall was empty. He imagined giving back the plate quietly and leaving Dev's name out of it. Then he saw Mrs Khan standing by the side door, her hands folded in front of her as if she were the person being inspected.
Amir stood up. His knees shook so sharply that they struck the chair in front. “Dev dropped it,” he said. His voice sounded small in the hall. He forced himself to continue. “And I helped him hide the damage.” He placed the engraved plate on his open palm.
Dev's face hardened, but after a long silence he rose too. “Amir didn't break it,” he said. “I did.”
At the end of the day, the cup was no longer in the cabinet. A clean square on the dusty shelf showed where it had stood. Dev was waiting by the school gate with a football beneath one arm.
“You made me look like a liar,” he said.
“You were letting Mrs Khan look like one,” Amir replied.
Dev looked down the road. He did not apologise. Instead, he rolled the ball towards Amir and said that he would tell the coach himself before training. Amir stopped the ball with his foot. For several seconds, neither boy moved; then they began walking, leaving a careful distance between them.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Amir behaves badly when he helps Dev hide the damage, but admitting the truth in front of everyone shows real courage.” Evaluate how far you agree. In your response, you could consider Amir's decision to help Dev, what happens when Mrs Khan is suspected and Amir's actions during the assembly. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer's methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.