The blue cards
Source: an original fiction extract.
Niamh found the cards outside the preparation room, scattered across the polished floor like pieces of blue glass. She recognised Dev’s handwriting before she read his name on the elastic band. His opening argument covered the first card in neat black lines. The second began with the statistic that had defeated her in the practice debate on Monday.
From inside the room came the scrape of a chair. Niamh gathered the cards quickly. She could have knocked on the door, but the competition organiser had told the finalists not to speak to one another during preparation time. She slid the bundle beneath her own notes and told herself that handing it over now would mean breaking a rule. The explanation was so useful that she did not examine it closely.
Ten minutes later, Dev appeared in the corridor without his jacket. He checked beneath the chairs and opened the same empty cupboard twice. Niamh watched through the narrow window in the preparation-room door. Without the cards, he would still be a strong speaker, she thought, but perhaps not strong enough. She imagined the judges announcing her name. In this version of the afternoon, nobody asked what she had seen on the floor.
Mrs Osei, the organiser, came along the corridor and asked whether anyone had found a bundle of blue cards. Niamh shook her head. As she did so, the corner of one card pressed against the side of her folder, making a small square shape beneath the cover. Mrs Osei’s eyes paused there, or seemed to. She said that all folders would be collected after the final so that the room could be cleared. Then she continued towards the hall.
Niamh carried the cards to the stage door. Dev was standing beside it, trying to reconstruct his argument on the back of the programme. She held out the bundle. For a moment, his relief made the decision feel generous. Then he asked when she had found them. Niamh could have said that she had only just noticed them. Instead, she told him about the corridor, the preparation room and Mrs Osei’s question. Dev took the cards without thanking her. ‘You let me search,’ he said. The call for the finalists came before she could reply.
Dev won by one point. Afterwards, Niamh’s coach said, ‘The judges knew he’d lost his cards, so they may have given him sympathy marks. We should ask for the result to be reviewed.’ Niamh looked across the hall. Dev was packing the blue cards into their elastic band, still without looking in her direction. ‘They heard nothing about the cards before the debate,’ she said. ‘He won.’
Near the exit, one card slipped from Dev’s folder. Niamh picked it up. The writing was facing her, but she turned the card over before carrying it to him. This time, she returned it at once.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “The ending is more concerned with the damage Niamh has done to her relationship with Dev than with suggesting that she has changed.” Evaluate how far you agree with this view. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.