The paper tower
Source: an original fiction extract.
Nisha arrived at the school exhibition carrying the tower with both hands. It was taller than her little brother and made entirely from folded paper, narrow strips of card and glue. Above the entrance to the hall, a banner announced the challenge: each model would be judged on height, strength and design. Nisha read the three words twice. She was confident about the first and had decided the other two would follow.
Joel was supposed to meet her at eight. At five past, she placed the tower on their table without him. She turned the label so that their names faced the judges’ route, although her own name was written slightly larger. Around her, other pairs opened boxes and compared notes. Nisha checked her phone. Joel had sent a message saying that his bus had broken down and he was walking from the next stop.
During the previous week, Joel had folded dozens of triangular supports for the tower’s base. They were strong, but their edges never met neatly. On Friday evening, after he had gone home, Nisha had removed most of them and rebuilt the upper section alone. The tower had gained twelve centimetres. She had not told him that it also trembled whenever somebody shut the classroom door.
At a quarter past eight, a caretaker asked her to move the model because the judges needed more space beside the entrance. Nisha slid her hands beneath the base. The tower leaned towards her. She could have waited, but Joel was still absent and the judges were already entering the hall. She lifted it.
A dry cracking sound came from somewhere inside the paper walls. Nisha froze. When she set the tower down on the new table, one corner of the base no longer touched the surface. She pressed it flat, but it rose again as soon as she removed her fingers.
Joel appeared carrying his bag and breathing hard. He did not ask why his original supports had disappeared. Instead, he walked around the table and watched the tower sway.
“We need to take the top section off,” he said.
“Then it won’t be the tallest.”
“It might still be standing.”
Nisha looked towards the judges. They were three tables away. Joel opened his bag. Inside were the triangular supports she had rejected, stacked in untidy bundles. He placed one beside the raised corner but did not attach it.
“You decide,” he said.
The tower seemed to be holding its breath. Nisha imagined the judges reaching their table just as the whole structure folded sideways. She also imagined removing the top section and watching another model win for height. Neither picture was acceptable, but only one left them with a tower.
“Help me cut it,” she said.
They worked without speaking. Nisha held the model steady while Joel removed the upper section. Together they fitted the triangular supports around the base. Their glue marks were visible and the repaired tower was no longer elegant, but when Joel took his hands away, it remained still.
The judges placed metal weights on a platform at the top. The tower held all of them. When one judge asked about the change in design, Nisha began, “I rebuilt—” and stopped. Joel waited.
“We made it too tall at first,” she said. “Then we changed the base.”
Their tower did not win the height prize. It received a special mention for adapting the design under pressure. After the exhibition, Nisha folded the results sheet and put it in her pocket without reading the individual scores.
“We can look at it on Monday,” she told Joel. “Before we build the next one.”
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “At first, Nisha treats the competition as something she must win alone. The writer shows that accepting Joel’s help changes her understanding of success without weakening her determination.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.