Before the microphone
Source: an original fiction extract.
Fifteen minutes before the assembly, Safiya arranged the speech inside a blue folder. The title page came first, followed by her introduction, the survey results and the conclusion. Every corner was aligned. Only Joel’s paragraph was missing. It was folded twice in the inside pocket of her blazer.
‘Have you got my page?’ Joel asked. He was searching through his rucksack, lifting out books and putting them back in again. At lunchtime, he had given the page to Safiya because she had offered to print the complete speech. ‘Maybe I left it near the printer.’
Safiya closed the folder. ‘Maybe.’
Joel’s paragraph described his first morning at the school, when he had stood alone outside the dining hall until an older pupil invited him inside. During their practice, the classroom had become unusually quiet as he read it. Their teacher had called it powerful. Safiya had looked down at her survey results and thought that they resembled labels on empty boxes. Later, while Joel was collecting their cue cards, she had removed his page. She told herself that the assembly had a strict time limit. She did not ask how long the paragraph took to read.
Chairs scraped across the hall as the first classes arrived. Joel checked beneath the table and behind the curtain. Safiya repeated her opening under her breath, but the sentences sounded different in the large room: neat, quick and strangely cold. On the stage, the microphone waited between two circles of light.
‘We’ll have to do it without my part,’ Joel said. He was holding a blank cue card. ‘You can read the whole thing.’
Their teacher looked towards them from the front row. ‘Start when you’re ready.’
Safiya could have walked to the microphone. Nobody had questioned the order of the pages, and Joel had already blamed himself. Instead, she reached into her pocket. The folded paragraph had become warm and soft at the edges.
‘You didn’t lose it,’ she said.
Joel stared at the page in her hand. Safiya explained that she had taken it because she thought it would make her section seem unimportant. Her explanation sounded smaller when spoken aloud. Joel unfolded the page carefully, pressing each crease with his thumb.
‘We won’t have time for everything now,’ he said.
Safiya removed her conclusion from the folder. ‘Then we leave this out.’
‘Because we need to save time?’
‘Because I took yours.’
When the assembly began, Joel walked to the microphone first. Halfway through his paragraph, he lost his place. Safiya knew the next sentence and almost supplied it, but she waited. Joel found the line himself. The hall remained silent until he finished, and then the applause arrived all at once.
Afterwards, their teacher congratulated them on working well together. Safiya felt Joel glance at her. ‘We didn’t, at first,’ she said, and explained what she had done. When they left the hall, Joel carried the blue folder. Safiya did not ask for it back.
Using the whole source, evaluate the view that:
‘Safiya begins by caring more about controlling the speech than about Joel, but her choices at the end show that she has genuinely become a better partner.’
Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
To help you plan, you may wish to consider:
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.