The taped course
Source: an original fiction extract.
The course had been marked across the hall with white tape, forming a route around foam walls and wooden blocks. At the far end stood a red box that each team's robot had to retrieve. Kai placed their machine behind the starting line and checked that its wheels were straight. The team had spent six Saturdays building it. Amara had designed the lifting arm, Lila had written the instructions it followed, and Kai had practised using the controller until he could guide it through the course without looking down. When the others asked whether he wanted one final trial, he said they should save the battery. He knew the machine better than anyone.
During the short test that morning, the robot had paused at an intersection and turned in a slow circle. Amara had suggested that a connector inside the casing might be loose. Kai said the polished floor was confusing the sensor. He restarted the machine, and it completed the rest of the route. Opening the casing would take several minutes and, worse, would make the team look unprepared while the judges were walking around. “It's fine,” he said. When Lila looked unconvinced, he said it again.
One of the judges stopped at their table before the demonstration. She asked whether they had experienced any problems during testing. Amara drew breath, but Kai answered first. He explained that they had adjusted the controls for the hall floor and were ready. The judge made a note and moved on. Amara asked why he had not mentioned the fault. Kai said there was no point damaging the judges' confidence over something that might not happen again. He held the controller between both hands, warm and solid, like an argument that could not be opened.
Their demonstration began well. The robot passed the first foam wall and pushed a wooden block aside. Kai heard Lila whisper the names of the turns as they approached. At the intersection, the machine stopped. Its wheels moved in opposite directions, twisting it back and forth across the tape. Kai pressed the controls harder. Amara told him to stop before the motor was strained. He said he could recover the route. The robot shot sideways and struck the foam wall, scattering it across the floor. Its display went dark.
Nobody in the audience laughed. That made the silence worse. Kai could see his own face in the blank display as he crouched beside the machine. The judge asked whether the team wished to continue. His thumb rested on the restart button. Then he stood up. “No,” he said. “We had a loose connection that we should have checked.” It was the first time he had described the problem without making it smaller.
The score for the course could not be changed, but the judge allowed the team to show how they would diagnose the fault. Kai passed the screwdriver to Amara. She removed the casing and pressed the connector firmly into place. The display lit at once. Lila entered a short instruction, and the lifting arm raised the red box from the floor. When Kai completed the team's log, he recorded the failed test and wrote that Amara had identified and repaired the fault. At the results table, he still watched each score as it was posted. But when the team photograph was taken, he put the controller down and stood beside the others.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Kai says he is protecting the team's chances, but the writer shows that pride leads him to conceal a fault and silence other people. By the end, he has begun to replace control with honesty and trust.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.