The first proof
Source: an original fiction extract.
Rowan had been alone in the print room for twenty-three minutes, which was exactly how she wanted it. The old press stood in the centre, black and complicated, while the type she had arranged waited inside its metal frame. She checked the date for the fourth time, then ran one finger beneath the line announcing the reopening of the hall. Around the words, she had built a border of leaves, each one angled differently so that the pattern seemed to move.
Mrs Hale had said that designing the commemorative print would be a useful exercise. Rowan had heard something more promising: proof that she could be trusted with important work. By the end of the afternoon, two hundred copies would be stacked on the front desk. Mrs Hale would see them whenever she entered the hall.
The door opened, admitting Dev and a stripe of cold corridor light. He had joined the workshop three Saturdays ago but already moved through it as though he knew which floorboards complained and which cupboards stuck.
"You're early," Rowan said.
"So are you." He put down his bag and studied the locked frame of type. "Want another pair of eyes before the first pull?"
Rowan placed both hands on the frame. "I've checked it."
Dev nodded. It was an ordinary nod, yet she found something patient in it, as if he had offered help to a child fastening a difficult button.
When the other volunteers arrived, they crowded around the press. Rowan rolled ink across the type and fitted the first sheet of thick paper into place. She had practised the sequence all week. Lever down, pressure, lever up. The press released the sheet with a soft tearing sound.
For a second, the result was better than she had imagined. The leaves were sharp and the letters stood dark against the cream paper. Then someone said, "Wasn't the hall reopened in 1986?"
Rowan looked at the date. The six and the eight had changed places.
Dev reached past her and caught the handle before she could begin the second print. His sleeve brushed the wet ink, leaving a black mark across his cuff.
"Good job you stopped it," one of the volunteers said.
Dev released the handle. "We caught it in time."
Rowan stared at the incorrect date. She remembered Dev standing beside the frame when he arrived. "You saw it earlier."
"I thought something looked wrong. That's why I asked if you wanted me to check."
"You could have said what you meant."
"I wasn't sure until it printed."
He spoke quietly, but the room had acquired the special silence in which quiet voices travel furthest.
Mrs Hale entered while Dev was replacing the two metal numbers. She listened to an account of the mistake from three people at once. Rowan waited for the part where somebody would explain that she had designed everything else correctly.
Mrs Hale examined the spoiled sheet. "A good catch," she said to Dev. Then she held it up to the light and looked again at the printed border. "And a good design, Rowan. Let's have the next one."
The second proof was correct. Everyone admired the leaves, though Rowan noticed they did so after Mrs Hale pointed them out. Dev stood beside the press with his stained cuff folded underneath his arm.
By midday, a neat stack of prints lay on the front desk. Visitors watched the press working and asked questions about the machinery. Because Dev happened to be operating it when the largest group arrived, he gave the explanation. He was good at it. He made the heavy press seem simple without making the work seem easy.
"Did you create the design as well?" a visitor asked him.
Dev glanced towards Rowan. She was only a few steps away, trimming the edge of a print.
"Rowan designed it," he said. "I mostly prevented us from celebrating the wrong year."
The visitors laughed. Rowan cut too deeply, shaving a narrow strip from the border. Dev's answer had given her the credit, but it had also preserved the story in which he rescued the whole afternoon. She wondered how many times he had already told it.
At closing time, Rowan found the spoiled first proof on the drying rack. Dev had written lightly on the back: First proof: Rowan's design, caught before the full run.
"I thought we could put it on the workshop wall," he said. "People only see the finished things."
Rowan read the sentence again. "Caught by whom?"
Dev looked at her, then at the black mark on his cuff. "Does that matter?"
To him, perhaps it did not. That was another kind of confidence.
Rowan considered tearing the sheet across the wrong date. Instead, she folded it once and placed it inside her folder. The error disappeared between the two halves, but the leaves remained visible.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Rowan's resentment comes mainly from her fear that one mistake will define her. The writer encourages us to distrust her view of Dev, although his behaviour is not entirely free from self-interest.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.