The blue fragment
Source: an original fiction extract.
For three mornings, Kian had sat at the recording table while the others worked inside the trench. He sharpened pencils, copied measurements and sealed scraps of pottery into numbered bags. Beyond the striped tape, volunteers moved slowly across squares of brown earth, brushing surfaces that appeared empty to him. Ms Adebayo called this patience. Kian thought it looked remarkably like finding nothing.
Shortly before lunch, he carried a tray of labelled bags to the storage tent. On his way back, a point of blue caught the light at the edge of the trench. It was no larger than the head of a drawing pin, but the colour was too sharp for the surrounding soil. He crouched beside it.
“I’ve found something,” he called.
Ms Adebayo was examining a dark line of earth at the opposite end. Without turning, she asked him to place a marker beside the blue point and wait. Kian pushed a white marker into the ground. He remained there for almost a minute, watching her measure the same dark line twice. Then one of the volunteers asked her a question, and she walked away from him.
Wait, Kian thought, was a word people used when they wanted a discovery to become somebody else’s.
His trowel was still on the recording table. He fetched it and carefully scraped away a thin layer of soil. The blue point became a square. Beside it appeared another, then a third. They curved towards the wall of the trench like the beginning of a necklace. Excitement made his hand feel both light and clumsy. He lifted the first square between his finger and thumb.
“Put that down,” Ms Adebayo said.
She was standing behind the tape. The other volunteers had turned to look. Kian held out the fragment, expecting her expression to change when she saw its colour. Instead, she asked exactly where it had been.
He pointed to the shallow hollow he had made.
“Exactly where?”
The hollow suddenly seemed much wider than his finger.
Ms Adebayo took a clear bag from her pocket and asked him to place the fragment inside. On the label, she wrote POSITION UNCERTAIN. Then she knelt beside the remaining squares. Her movements were so controlled that Kian could not tell whether she was angry. She asked for the site plan and handed him a pencil.
“Draw what is still here.”
His first lines were quick and dark. She made him measure the distance between each square and the trench wall. As he added the figures, the marks on the paper formed a curve more clearly than the fragments did in the soil. Ms Adebayo covered the area before the afternoon rain and announced that the trench would be extended in the morning.
By the end of the next day, the team had uncovered part of a broad circular pattern. Everyone offered an opinion about what the missing section might have looked like. Kian could see where the fragment in the bag appeared to fit, but whenever he suggested placing it in the gap, Ms Adebayo said that appearing to fit was not the same as knowing.
A visitor asked who had made the discovery. One of the volunteers pointed towards Kian, but Ms Adebayo replied, “Kian noticed the first sign.” Her careful choice of words irritated him more than if she had said nothing. The trench would not have been extended without him. Yet the plan displayed for visitors carried the whole team’s names, printed at the same size.
That evening, Ms Adebayo found him packing the recording table. She laid the original plan beside him. Beneath the measurements, in her small square handwriting, she had added: EXTENSION PROPOSED AFTER KIAN MALIK’S OBSERVATION.
“Tomorrow, you can supervise the measurements,” she said. “If you can bear to do nothing quickly.”
Kian looked towards the trench, where the blue curve remained under its cover. The loose fragment was still on the table. For a moment, he imagined slipping it into the gap before anyone arrived. Instead, he checked that the bag was sealed and placed it with the numbered finds.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Kian’s impatience is presented as the real force behind the discovery, while Ms Adebayo’s caution mainly protects rules and prevents him receiving credit.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.