The repair bench
Source: an original fiction extract.
By ten o’clock, Nabil had made the radio quieter, but not better. Its wooden case stood open on the repair bench, giving off a smell of dust whenever he moved it. Around him, the Saturday workshop continued successfully: a lamp shone again; a drawer slid smoothly; somebody tested a newly mended umbrella beneath an imaginary rain cloud. Nabil kept his eyes on the radio. It was the first object Mrs Keane had allowed him to repair without another volunteer beside him, and he wanted her to return from the storeroom after everything difficult was over.
Meera stopped on her way to the door. She had already put on her coat and was checking the time. ‘Still fighting you?’ she asked. Nabil said the radio was nearly done. Meera listened to the thin whistle from the speaker, then leaned over the open case without touching it. She asked what happened when he pressed one of the wires. The whistle vanished. When he released it, the sound returned. Meera pointed to a dull patch where the wire joined the board. ‘I’d look there,’ she said. ‘But my bus won’t wait for a successful diagnosis.’ She picked up her bag and left while Nabil was reaching for his tools.
The repair took six minutes. When Nabil switched the radio on again, music filled the bench clearly enough to make two volunteers applaud. Mrs Keane came back carrying a box of labels. ‘Your first one on your own,’ she said. Before Nabil could answer, she wrote his name on a card and placed it in front of the radio. The words looked more official than he felt: REPAIRED BY NABIL HUSSAIN. He considered explaining that Meera had noticed the fault, but Mrs Keane was already calling across the room for someone to fetch the radio’s owner. Nabil told himself that noticing was not repairing. He had held the tool, made the join and tested the result. The card did not say that nobody had helped him.
Meera returned a few minutes later because she had left her gloves on a chair. She paused when she saw the card. ‘Neat lettering,’ she said. Nabil replied that Mrs Keane had written it without asking. ‘You only pointed at the problem,’ he added. The word ‘only’ sounded ungenerous once it was in the room, but Meera nodded. ‘And you solved it,’ she said. She put on her gloves one finger at a time. Nabil waited for her to say something else. When she did not, he felt relieved, which was almost as uncomfortable as feeling guilty.
The owner, Mr Vale, arrived with Mrs Keane. He explained that the radio had belonged to his wife and that he had expected to take it home as an ornament rather than hear it again. He asked who had found the fault. Mrs Keane touched the card with one finger. ‘Our newest repairer.’ Mr Vale shook Nabil’s hand before Nabil had decided whether to correct her. Then Mrs Keane announced that the workshop’s hundredth successful repair would be recorded in its monthly newsletter. Nabil looked at the card again. Until that moment, it had seemed temporary. Now he imagined his name printed beneath an account of the repair and Meera reading it later, when her quiet agreement could no longer protect him from looking dishonest.
Mrs Keane began asking Nabil questions about how he had repaired the radio, so she could include the details in the newsletter. Meera moved towards the doorway, but Mrs Keane called her back and asked whether she had seen the radio working before she left. Nabil heard the story taking shape around his name. ‘Wait,’ he said. Mrs Keane put down her pen. Nabil explained that Meera had identified the faulty connection and that he had completed the repair. Mrs Keane looked from him to Meera. Mr Vale said that sounded like a successful workshop to him.
Afterwards, Mrs Keane removed the card and asked what the replacement should say. Nabil suggested both names. Meera said the radio would not care whose names were in front of it, but she took the pen when he offered it. She wrote REPAIRED TOGETHER, leaving no room for either name. Nabil placed the new card against the radio. He was glad the newsletter account had not yet been written. He could not decide whether this was because the corrected version was fairer or because it was the version he would now be seen beside.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Nabil admits Meera’s contribution, but the writer suggests that he speaks mainly to protect his own reputation rather than because he has become fair-minded.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.