The cliff count
By seven, Niko was alone in the observation hut above the cliffs. The room contained a narrow bench, two pairs of binoculars and a clock whose second hand caught slightly at the top of each minute. On the bench lay the survey sheet. Every ten minutes, the observer recorded the number of birds crossing the headland. If mist or rain made a reliable count impossible, the instructions said to leave the box empty. At noon, the figures would be sent to the main station.
This was Niko’s final week as a volunteer. The coordinator had said she would write him a reference if his work remained accurate. All morning, the birds passed in clear groups: twenty-two, then nineteen, then fifty-eight. Niko wrote each figure carefully and added his initials. When Elsie arrived to take over the second pair of binoculars, he moved his notebook aside so that she could see the neat column of numbers.
At eleven forty, mist climbed over the edge of the cliff and erased the headland. Niko counted eleven birds before the grey closed around them. He could still hear wings beyond the window, quick and numerous, but he could see nothing. The empty box on the survey sheet seemed larger than the others. After a moment, he wrote 63. It was close to the previous count and looked, he thought, like the sort of number an experienced observer might record. When Elsie asked whether he was certain, he kept his eyes on the window and said that he was.
The coordinator returned five minutes before noon. She ran her finger down the column and stopped at 63. Niko watched the pencil mark become faintly blurred beneath her fingertip. ‘That is a lot of birds for this visibility,’ she said. Elsie leaned across the bench. Her initials appeared beside the previous entry, close enough to the new figure for the two lines to seem connected. Niko heard himself say, ‘We changed over around then.’ The sentence did not accuse Elsie, but it left a space in which she might be blamed. His reflection in the dark window looked calm; only the pulse beside his thumb betrayed him.
The coordinator turned towards Elsie. Before she could speak, Niko pulled the sheet back. ‘The number may not be reliable,’ he said. At first he called it a recording error. Then, as the coordinator waited, he explained that he had seen only eleven birds and had estimated the rest. The word ‘estimated’ sounded careful and almost professional, so he made himself add, ‘I invented it.’ The coordinator drew one line through 63 and wrote count obscured by mist. Niko asked to telephone the main station himself. During the call, he described the correction clearly, although he was relieved when no one asked for his name.
Afterwards, he signed the amended entry with his full name instead of his initials. When the mist thinned, fourteen birds crossed the headland. Niko counted them twice before writing. At the next interval, the cliff vanished again, and he left the box empty. The blank no longer looked careless, but honest. As the coordinator collected the sheets, Niko hoped she would notice his full signature. He also hoped that, when she wrote the reference, she would remember everything except the reason it was there.
Focus on the final four paragraphs, from ‘At eleven forty’ to the end.
A reader said: ‘Niko’s final actions are responsible, but the writer suggests that protecting his reputation matters to him as much as correcting the record.’
To what extent do you agree and/or disagree? Evaluate how the writer presents Niko in these paragraphs, using evidence and analysis of the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.