The last hive
Source: an original fiction extract.
Sana had spent the morning preparing the observation hive for the community garden's summer fair. The bees were sealed behind glass so visitors could watch them safely, and Mr Vale had trusted her to carry the wooden box from the store. As she turned through the narrow doorway, one corner struck the frame with a hard click. She examined the glass and saw nothing broken. When Mr Vale called to ask whether everything was ready, she answered yes.
By noon, a crowd had gathered around the demonstration table. Mr Vale introduced Sana as the garden's youngest volunteer, and people applauded. While he described the hive, Sana noticed a pale line across one side of the wooden frame. She placed her thumb over it. The line might have been there before, she thought. When Mr Vale asked whether she was ready to remove the cloth, she nodded.
When Mr Vale lifted the cloth, the pale line widened. A bee pushed its head into the gap and withdrew. Sana heard herself say, ‘Wait.’ She pulled the cloth down so quickly that it knocked over the jar of flowers beside the hive. The crowd fell silent. Mr Vale asked what was wrong. Sana kept her thumb against the frame and said that the box might have been damaged. His eyes moved from her hand to the doorway of the store. ‘Might have been?’ he asked.
Sana told him about the knock. Mr Vale fastened the cloth around the hive and carried it into the locked shed. When the organiser asked whether the demonstration was cancelled, he said it would not continue until the box had been inspected. Sana followed him, apologising. ‘I didn't want to ruin the day,’ she said. Mr Vale set the hive down carefully. ‘You nearly made that decision for everyone when you kept quiet.’
Back at the empty table, Sana asked if she could speak to the waiting visitors. Mr Vale watched her for a moment, then stepped aside. Sana explained that she had damaged the box and should have reported it immediately. She did not mention that she had been the one to stop the demonstration until someone in the crowd thanked her. The applause this time was quieter. Sana could not tell whether it was meant to forgive her or to send her away. As the crowd dispersed, a child remained beside the table, staring past her at the locked shed.
Focus on the final three paragraphs, from ‘When Mr Vale lifted the cloth’ to the end.
Evaluate the writer's choice to end with the child looking past Sana at the locked shed. How far does this ending make the reader revise any admiration created by Sana's warning and public confession?
Base your judgement on the whole of this section and on the effects of the writer's choices.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.