The blue fragment
Source: an original fiction extract.
On the first morning of the community dig, Mara was given a trowel, a brush and a square marked D6. The excavation occupied the ground behind the old assembly rooms, where neat lines of string divided the soil into boxes. To Mara, each one looked like a sealed promise. On the information board were photographs of objects found in previous years: a buckle, a painted cup, a coin with a worn face. She imagined another photograph being added, with her name printed beneath it. When the supervisor reminded everyone that careful records mattered more than impressive discoveries, Mara wrote the date at the top of her sheet in her best handwriting.
By midday, D6 had produced a rusted nail and two plain pieces of pottery. Mara measured the position of each object before placing it in a numbered bag. She did everything correctly, yet the tray beside her remained disappointingly empty. In the next square, Theo uncovered a piece of patterned tile. People gathered while the supervisor cleaned it with a soft brush. Mara said it was beautiful, although the word arrived slightly later than her smile. As soon as the others moved away, she began working faster. The flat side of her trowel left bright marks in the soil.
Near the end of the afternoon, something blue shone in the narrow ridge between D6 and Theo's square. The ridge was supposed to remain untouched until the measurements had been checked. Mara leaned closer. The fragment might be glass, or stone, or something nobody had seen before. With one careful movement, she shaved a thin layer from the side of the ridge. The blue object shifted and dropped into D6. No one looked up. She placed her trowel across the spot.
A group of visiting children arrived as the supervisor was explaining Theo's tile. “Finding an object is only half the work,” she told them. “If we lose its exact position, we tear away part of its story.” Mara stared at the numbered bags in her tray. When the supervisor came to inspect D6, Mara said that she thought she might have disturbed the edge of the square. She did not explain how. The supervisor thanked her for reporting it, marked the area and told her not to remove anything until it had been examined. Mara felt relieved that no one asked why the soil there was already loose.
Rain came suddenly the next morning. Water gathered in the paths and began to creep towards the open squares. Everyone worked to cover the excavation. Mara held down a sheet while Theo fixed its corners, then chased a label that had blown beneath a wheelbarrow. For several minutes, nobody mentioned discoveries. They counted bags, checked numbers and carried trays into the assembly rooms. Mara noticed that Theo's patterned tile looked ordinary among all the muddy fragments waiting to be washed.
When the rain passed, the supervisor recovered the blue object from where it had fallen inside D6. It was a thick piece of modern bottle glass. Mara laughed more loudly than anyone else, then became quiet. She spent the final hour washing the plain pottery from D6. On one piece, she noticed two tiny holes where a crack had once been repaired. She recorded the detail and wrote the trench team's code in the space for the finder. Before leaving, she glanced once at the information board where future photographs would appear. Then she went back to help Theo stack the trays.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Mara is drawn to the dig by what the soil might be hiding, but what she really wants is to be known as the person who finds something important. The writer exposes this vanity, though by the end the dig’s careful routines are starting to change her.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.