The flood log
Source: an original fiction extract.
Leah had not been meant to run the river control station alone. Mr Howes was supposed to have arrived before dark, but a fallen tree had blocked the road from the town. His last message had told her to wait, keep the radio switched on and record every change in the log.
The control room was hardly a room at all: a metal desk, a wall of switches and a window overlooking the channel. Rain crawled down the glass in crooked lines. On the desk, the station manual lay open at the page for the south gate. The instruction was printed inside a red box: the gate must not be opened without permission from the duty engineer. If released, the water would spread across the recreation field instead of continuing towards the cottages on Mill Row.
Leah wrote the time beside the first movement of the gauge needle. Underneath, she added, ‘Duty engineer delayed by blocked road.’ Her writing was small and exact. She checked the clock before putting a full stop at the end. When the radio produced only a burst of static, she recorded that too.
Kit arrived through the side door with rain shining on his coat. He maintained the station machinery during the day, but he was not authorised to operate the gates. Without greeting her, he looked at the gauge.
‘It’s still rising.’
‘I’ve written that down.’ Leah moved the log closer to herself.
Kit wiped the window with his sleeve. Beyond the channel, the lamps of Mill Row appeared and disappeared behind the rain. ‘The recreation field is empty,’ he said. ‘The cottages aren’t.’
Leah placed one finger on the red box in the manual. ‘Mr Howes said to wait.’
‘He said to keep a record as well. That doesn’t mean the record will stop the water.’
The radio crackled before Leah could answer. Mr Howes’s voice came through thinly, broken by interference. ‘Leah, listen carefully. If the needle reaches the black line, you must—’
The rest vanished beneath a roar of static.
Leah called his name until her throat hurt. There was no reply. She entered the message in the log exactly as she had heard it, including the final word, ‘must’. Then she wrote, ‘Instruction incomplete,’ and underlined it twice.
The needle continued its slow climb. Kit stood beside the cabinet containing the gate controls, but he did not touch it. Leah knew what the unfinished message probably meant. She also knew what the manual said. She imagined Mr Howes arriving later and asking why she had disobeyed a printed instruction. She imagined him asking a different question while water stood in the kitchens of Mill Row.
A wheelie bin floated into view below the window. It moved along the road with absurd dignity, upright and turning gently, until the current knocked it against a garden wall. Leah had passed that wall every morning on her way to the station. Now only its top row of bricks remained visible.
‘Write that down,’ Kit said quietly.
Leah looked at the log. Until then, each sentence had recorded an external event: the road had been blocked, the message had been interrupted, the needle had risen. None stated a decision Leah had made.
She opened the control cabinet. The south-gate lever was taller than she had expected. Beside it, a white card repeated the warning from the manual.
‘You don’t have to do it,’ Kit said.
Leah almost laughed. It was the first useless thing he had said.
She returned to the desk and wrote one final entry before touching the lever. This time she did not use her initials. She wrote her full name, followed by the words, ‘I opened the south gate.’ Her hand shook so badly that the last letter crossed the line beneath it.
The lever resisted, then moved. Somewhere beyond the wall, machinery answered with a deep metallic clang that Leah felt through the floor. The gauge needle trembled. For several seconds it did nothing else.
Kit watched the channel. Leah watched the needle. When it finally edged away from the black line, neither of them spoke. She placed the manual beside the log rather than closing it. Then she picked up the pen again and waited to see what she would have to record next.
Consider the source as a whole. A student has said: “At first, Leah mainly uses rules and record-keeping to avoid responsibility. By the end, she is confident enough to trust her own judgement.”
Evaluate the student’s view. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.