The worn place
Source: an original fiction extract.
The repair workshop opened on the first Saturday of each month in the hall behind the library. Leena arrived while Mr Sayeed was still testing the lights and laid the screwdrivers in a straight line. Next month, he would choose someone to hold the spare key. Leena had not asked whether he was considering her.
Mr Vale brought the clock wrapped in a faded tea towel. Its square wooden case was dry at the corners, and one side carried a dark oval where the grain was almost hidden. ‘It was my wife’s,’ he said. ‘I don’t need it looking new. I miss hearing it.’ When Leena asked whether he wanted the case treated as well, someone called him from the doorway. ‘Do whatever keeps it going,’ he said, before leaving.
Leena photographed the clock from every side. She placed each screw in a labelled cup and rested the brass hands on folded paper. Inside, old oil had thickened around two wheels, and a narrow metal pin had bent just enough to catch once during every turn. She cleaned the wheels, straightened the pin and tested the movement without forcing it.
Mr Sayeed examined the wooden case while she worked. ‘Dry enough to split one day,’ he said. ‘If you wax it, the surface will need cleaning first. Your judgement.’ He moved on to a lamp at the next table. Leena repeated the final two words silently. They sounded like permission, but also like a test.
Shortly after midday, she fitted the hands back into place and turned the key. The clock gave three uneven beats before settling into a steady rhythm. Mr Sayeed glanced across and nodded, then returned to the lamp. Leena waited for him to say something more.
The first wipe removed a grey film from the wood. The darker oval remained beneath it. Leena could have applied the wax around the mark, although the colour would not have been even. She turned the clock towards the window and imagined it on the completed shelf beside the other repairs, each with the volunteer’s name written on a card. Then she passed the cloth across the oval. Brown gathered in the fabric until the whole side became pale and smooth.
‘Neat work,’ Mr Sayeed said when he returned. He pressed a thumbnail gently against one dry corner. ‘That should last.’ Leena wrote her name on the repair card and placed it beneath the clock.
Mr Vale came back while the tables were being folded. Leena wound the clock and set it between them. As the ticking filled the space, he closed his eyes and smiled. He asked how often it would need winding and listened carefully to her answer. Only then did he turn the clock and notice the cleaned side.
His thumb moved over the pale wood. ‘She steadied it there every morning,’ he said. ‘The mark appeared slowly. I used to complain about it.’ He gave a short laugh, but continued rubbing the same place. ‘After she died, I was glad I hadn’t cleaned it.’
Leena looked towards the tins on the workshop shelf. ‘I could darken the wood again.’
‘It wouldn’t be the same mark.’
She began to say that the case had been dry and that cleaning helped the wax hold evenly. The explanation was true, but it no longer seemed to answer him. ‘I’m sorry,’ she said.
Mr Vale placed the clock under his arm without wrapping it. ‘You brought the sound back,’ he said. Before leaving, he asked Leena to show him once more which way to turn the key. At the door, he paused and listened. The clock had not missed a beat. He smiled and walked on, his thumb resting on the pale place where the oval had been.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Leena’s wish to prove that she can be trusted affects her judgement, but the writer does not present the repair as simply a failure: she preserves something important for Mr Vale while also removing something important.” Evaluate how far you agree with this view. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.