For six days, Lewis had been emptying his mother's flat into labelled boxes. The buyer would collect the keys on Friday, and the clearance company was due on Thursday. Lewis worked steadily through the kitchen and bedrooms, keeping receipts in one envelope and spare keys in another. Only the sewing room remained. His sister Mara had sent a message asking him not to clear it until she had seen it. Lewis read the message, placed his phone face down and carried another box to the car.
Mara had not entered the flat since the argument five years earlier. Lewis had stayed nearby, arranging appointments and repairing whatever broke. Whenever their mother asked whether Mara might visit, he had answered that she knew the address. He had repeated this so often that it had become, in his mind, an explanation rather than an accusation.
In the sewing room, he found a biscuit tin beneath a folded blanket. It contained birthday cards addressed to Mara in their mother's handwriting, none of them stamped. Beneath the cards lay letters from Mara, their envelopes opened and their postmarks spread across all five years. On the final envelope, his mother had written in pencil: Lewis says you need time. I won't press. Lewis read the sentence twice. He remembered telling her to stop waiting by the window, though he could not remember using those exact words.
When the clearance van arrived on Thursday, Lewis told the men to leave the sewing room untouched. The driver warned him that a second visit would cost extra. Lewis signed the amended form without asking the price. After they had gone, he recorded a message for Mara. ‘I found the cards Mum wrote to you. I found your letters too. I had no right to say you had stopped caring.’ His voice sounded small in the stripped room. He suggested meeting at the café opposite the flat on Saturday and added, ‘You don't have to answer now.’ Before he could replay the message, he pressed send.
On Saturday, Lewis chose a table from which he could see both the café door and the clock. The letters were in a box beneath his chair. By five minutes to six, he had checked the clock eleven times. A waitress began wiping the empty tables and asked whether he wanted anything else. Lewis looked through the window at the dark flat, then ordered another pot of tea. At three minutes past six, Mara entered wearing her coat and carrying nothing. Lewis rose halfway before sitting down again. She remained beside the door and asked, ‘Did Mum read my letters?’ Lewis had practised a much longer speech, but he answered, ‘Yes.’ He kept his hands still on the table and waited for her next question.
Focus on the final two paragraphs, from ‘When the clearance van arrived’ to the end.
A reader said: ‘Lewis begins to accept responsibility for the separation from Mara, but his attempt to repair their relationship remains cautious and shaped by his fear of her response.’
To what extent do you agree and/or disagree? Evaluate how the writer presents Lewis's reactions and decisions in this part of the extract. In your response, consider what his final decision suggests about how he may respond to Mara in future.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.