The unprinted article
Source: an original fiction extract.
The volunteer magazine occupied two rooms above a pharmacy. On press evenings, the larger room filled with marked proofs, empty cups and the dry clicking of keyboards. Kemi had spent a week preparing her first article: a profile of Mrs Adebayo, who had founded the town’s youth club thirty years earlier. Mara, the editor, had praised the opening and moved the article to the front of the magazine. Kemi had already imagined taking a copy to Mrs Adebayo on Saturday.
Forty minutes before the files were due to be sent to the printer, Mara called Kemi over. A sentence near the end of the article had been highlighted. It was the sentence on which the whole conclusion rested, but the recording of the interview became silent for twelve seconds at exactly that point. Kemi opened her notebook. Parts of the quotation appeared there, but on separate pages beneath different questions. She said she remembered Mrs Adebayo joining the ideas together. Mara read the pages again and then said that the article could not appear in that issue.
‘Take out the quotation and keep the rest,’ Leon suggested from the next desk. He meant it kindly. Kemi looked at the final paragraphs and saw how they collapsed without it. Mara tapped the highlighted sentence. ‘The writing is yours. The certainty isn’t.’ The two short statements seemed to Kemi like a door closing twice. Mara added that she did not believe Kemi had invented anything. ‘But believing you is not the same as asking every reader to believe us.’ Kemi closed her notebook so sharply that Leon stopped typing.
Mara explained that there were thirty-five minutes left. She could replace the ending herself, but then Kemi’s name would appear above sentences she had not written. Alternatively, the article could wait until the next issue. She placed the marked proof and a blank sheet beside one another. ‘You may stay, or you may go home. You do not have to make this useful tonight.’ Kemi wanted an apology for the empty space that would appear where her article had been planned. Mara did not offer one. She returned to the main desk and began checking the contents page.
Kemi reached the stairs before turning back. At the smallest desk, she listened to the interview again and compared each answer with her notes. The phrase about giving young people ‘a room of their own’ was clear. The words about allowing them to ‘save themselves’ belonged to an earlier answer. Nothing proved that Mrs Adebayo had placed the two ideas in one sentence. Kemi drafted a message asking her to confirm exactly what she had meant. When she showed it to Mara, Mara moved the magazine’s address out of the sender box. ‘Ask her in your own name,’ she said. Kemi sent the message, drew a line through the unsupported quotation and began a new ending with the words she could verify. Shortly after midnight, the first copy of the magazine came from the printer without her article. It weighed exactly the same as the others, although Kemi held it with both hands.
Focus on the final three paragraphs, from ‘Take out the quotation’ to the end.
A reader commented: ‘Mara supports Kemi by protecting both the readers and Kemi’s ownership of the article, but her refusal to soften the decision makes that support difficult to recognise.’
To what extent do you agree and/or disagree with this view? Evaluate how the writer presents Mara’s treatment of Kemi and Kemi’s changing response. Use evidence from the text and analyse the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.