The speaking order
Source: an original fiction extract.
Leah had been waiting for the final round since October. She had rewritten her speech on the bus, in the lunch queue and once beneath the desk during registration. Now only Samir stood between her and the silver cup on the judges' table.
He was due to speak first. As the chairperson called his name, Samir stood too quickly and caught his sleeve on the elastic around his speech cards. The elastic snapped. Cards slid beneath chairs, landed face down in the aisle and skated almost as far as the judges.
For a second, no one moved. Leah saw the opening paragraph near her shoe. Another card had disappeared beneath the radiator. Samir was gathering them without looking at the words, his hands moving faster each time he dropped one.
The chairperson checked the clock. ‘Two minutes,’ she said. ‘Then we must begin.’
Leah could have remained seated. Helping an opponent was not part of the rules, and Samir had brought the cards badly fastened. She imagined herself walking to the front while he was still trying to decide which argument came second. The thought was not pleasant, exactly, but it was bright and tempting.
Then she picked up the paragraph beside her shoe.
‘The numbers are in the bottom corner,’ she said. She crawled between the chairs and reached beneath the radiator. Samir spread the cards across the floor while Leah ordered them into piles. Number seven was missing until she found it resting against the leg of the judges' table. She handed him the completed stack with twelve seconds left.
During Samir's speech, Leah recognised every card she had touched. He spoke without looking down for long, building each point carefully before turning it against the next. When the audience laughed at his final example, Leah laughed too, half a second after everyone else. She was glad the cards had not ruined him. She also wished, fiercely, that the room had been quieter.
Her own speech went well. She slowed down where she had practised slowing down and remembered the final sentence without checking her notes. When the judges returned, the chief judge said that only one point separated the finalists.
Samir won.
Leah applauded because the whole room was applauding. Her palms met neatly while disappointment tightened behind her ribs. Samir carried the cup towards her before anyone could take the official photograph.
‘You saved my speech,’ he said.
‘I saved your cards,’ Leah replied. ‘You still had to deliver it.’
Their teacher told Leah that she had been wonderfully gracious. Leah disliked the word at once. It made losing sound smooth and effortless, when she could already list three sentences she should have changed.
Outside the hall, Samir asked whether she would practise with him before next term's competition.
‘Only if you buy a stronger elastic band,’ she said.
He laughed, and this time Leah did not have to wait before joining him. She kept the result sheet folded in her pocket, with the one-point difference facing inwards.
Consider the whole source. A student said: “The writer shows that Leah's generosity towards Samir is genuine, even though it does nothing to soften her desire to win.” Evaluate how far you agree with this statement. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer's methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.