The unsigned letter
Source: an original fiction extract.
The letter had been folded into a square so small that Nell needed both hands to open it. She found it behind a loose board in the village hall, where she had been sorting papers for a local display. There was no name on the envelope, only the words “For whoever comes next”. Nell read the letter once, then again, and put it beside the blank caption card.
“We should leave before the lamps go out,” it said. “I can’t explain it here. You know what happened by the steps.” The final line had been torn away. Nell tapped the card with her pen. A secret meeting, perhaps. A warning. The hall had been used for all sorts of gatherings, and she could already picture visitors leaning close to the display, trying to work out who had written it. She began: A message from someone forced to leave the village. The sentence looked confident. It also looked good in the space.
Mr Iles, who had helped her carry the boxes, read over her shoulder. “Do we know that?” he asked. He did not sound accusing. He was folding a piece of brown paper into quarters, carefully matching the corners.
Nell glanced again at the envelope. The paper was clean, the fold sharp. There was no postmark, no address, nothing to show whether it had ever been sent. She rubbed the edge of the torn line with her thumb, as if the missing words might rise through it. “Someone wanted it kept,” she said.
“Or someone wanted it hidden,” said Mr Iles. He set the paper down. Nell looked towards the hall steps through the open door. They were just steps: worn in the middle, pale where feet had passed. The letter might have meant these, or another set entirely. She crossed out her sentence. The ink left a dark bar through forced to leave.
She tried again, writing slowly this time: An unsigned letter, found behind a board in the village hall. Its writer refers to leaving and to “the steps”, but the reason is unknown. She read it aloud. It sounded meagre beside the letter's little drama. It also left the visitors with nowhere obvious to go next.
Mr Iles nodded, but Nell could not tell whether he approved or was simply ready to finish. She placed the letter beneath a clear cover and set the caption beside it. For a moment, she considered adding a question for visitors: What do you think happened? Instead, she put down her pen. The blank strip beneath the caption seemed larger than before. When the first visitors arrived, Nell stood beside the display and listened to them read. One woman turned to her and asked who had written the letter. Nell began to answer, then looked again at the torn edge. “We don’t know,” she said. The woman looked back at the display. Nell stayed where she was.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Nell’s final decision is presented as an honest refusal to invent a story, but it may also be a way of avoiding the risk of making a judgement.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.