The twelfth letter
Source: an original fiction extract.
The metal box stood on a towel in the assembly room, still carrying a rectangle of damp earth on its lid. It had been lifted from the school courtyard the previous afternoon, after thirty years underground. Beside it, the headteacher had placed a typed list of twelve names. Inside the box lay eleven envelopes.
Celia Blake's name was the last on the list. Jay looked from the empty space in the box to the visitors gathered around it. Celia stood nearest the door, one hand in her coat pocket.
“Perhaps I never put mine in,” she said, although nobody had yet asked her.
The previous afternoon, Jay had gone to the archive room to collect some folding chairs. Celia had been there alone. The metal box was on the table, and one edge of its lid seemed to be raised by the width of a coin. Celia had stepped between Jay and the table.
“I was looking for the old photographs,” she had told him.
At the time, this had seemed explanation enough. Now, with eleven envelopes arranged beneath twelve names, Jay remembered the narrow darkness under the lid.
Mr Dale, the caretaker, interrupted his thoughts. He had fixed a numbered strip across the box before locking the archive room and had cut it himself that morning. The strip had been unbroken, he insisted. When Jay mentioned the raised lid, Mr Dale shook his head.
“The metal's bent. From the doorway, it always looks open.”
Celia leaned over the box. She said she remembered the day it had been buried: the hurried line of pupils, the first drops of rain striking the lid and the teacher calling for everyone to return inside. In her account, she had waited until the others moved away before pushing her envelope through the slot. She even remembered the soft sound it made as it landed.
Ruth Morgan, another former pupil, remembered something different. Celia had written only one sentence, Ruth said, and then refused to hand it in. Ruth could still picture her walking away with the envelope folded beneath her exercise book. Yet when the headteacher asked what that sentence had been, Ruth admitted that Celia had never shown it to her.
An old film of the burial was projected onto the wall. The silent figures moved too quickly beneath a pale, jumping sky. Celia appeared at the edge of the picture with a white envelope in her hand. She approached the box. For three seconds, Ruth passed directly in front of the camera. When Celia came back into view, both her hands were empty.
“There,” said Celia.
“That proves you walked away,” Ruth replied. “Nothing else.”
As the visitors began examining the other letters, Jay picked up the typed list. Its heading read, Letters prepared for the time capsule. On the reverse, in faded pencil, someone had written beside Celia's name: not yet handed in. The list was dated the day before the burial.
Jay looked again at Celia's hand, still hidden in her pocket. Not yet was not the same as never, but it was no longer the same as missing.
Consider the whole source. Analyse how the writer structures the different accounts of the twelfth letter to shape the reader's judgement of Celia. In your response, consider the contradictions created by shifts in time and perspective, and reach a judgement about how far the final discovery resolves them. Support your explanation with references to the source.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.