The red holds
Source: an original fiction extract.
At seven on Sunday morning, the climbing centre belonged to Celeste. She unlocked the side entrance for Jade, switched on one row of lights and led her past the silent reception desk. The public session would not begin for another three hours. Celeste had booked the main wall herself and refused Jade’s offer to contribute towards the cost.
‘You need space to concentrate,’ she said. ‘Today, nobody gets in the way.’
A route of red holds crossed the wall from left to right. Beside it, Celeste had placed a chair, a bottle of water and a clipboard covered in small, exact handwriting. Jade’s name appeared at the top of every page. Underneath were columns headed TIME, ERROR and CORRECTION.
Jade pointed towards the green route. ‘Could I warm up on that one?’
Celeste did not look up from the clipboard. ‘The green route encourages you to reach with the wrong hand.’ She tapped the lowest red hold with her pen. ‘Start here.’
During the first attempt, Celeste called each movement before Jade made it. Left foot. Higher. Wait. Now reach. When Jade paused to choose between two holds, Celeste repeated the instruction more loudly, as if distance rather than uncertainty had prevented her from obeying. At the ground, she tightened Jade’s harness, retied the knot and rubbed chalk from Jade’s fingers before replacing it with a thinner layer.
‘Small details,’ she said. ‘That is what keeps good climbers from wasting years.’
On the third attempt, Jade ignored the next red hold and stretched towards a grey one above it. Her foot slipped. The rope tightened at once, leaving her suspended a short distance from the wall. Celeste lowered her carefully and checked the harness before allowing her to stand.
‘That is why I plan the sequence,’ Celeste said. She sounded neither angry nor frightened. She sounded satisfied.
During the break, Celeste poured tea from a flask and gave Jade the larger cup. She explained that, when she had been Jade’s age, no coach had corrected her technique. By the time somebody did, she had spent two years practising the same mistakes. ‘I’m not letting that happen to you,’ she said. Her voice softened, and for a moment the clipboard lay forgotten beneath her chair.
Jade asked whether Noor could come to the next session. Noor had also missed selection for the regional squad, and they usually trained together.
Celeste picked up the clipboard. ‘Noor climbs by instinct. You’re different.’ She drew a line through the unfinished record of Jade’s third attempt. ‘You could be excellent, if we remove the habits that are holding you back.’
The words should have sounded encouraging. Instead, Jade imagined Celeste taking her apart like a machine, examining each piece and returning only the ones she approved of.
For the final climb, Celeste told Jade to repeat the red route without stopping. Halfway up, Jade chose the grey hold again. This time her foot remained steady. She crossed above Celeste’s planned sequence and reached the top by a line of holds that was slower, less graceful and entirely her own.
Celeste kept the rope secure until Jade returned to the floor. Then she studied the wall rather than Jade. ‘Again,’ she said. ‘Using the red holds properly this time.’
At reception, Celeste wrote JADE — PRIVATE SESSION in the booking diary for the following Sunday. Jade took the pen before Celeste could close the book and added AND NOOR. Celeste read the altered entry, folded the page along its centre and pressed the crease flat with her thumbnail.
‘We’ll see,’ she said.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “The writer presents Celeste’s extra coaching as generous on the surface, but mainly as a way for her to control Jade.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.