The warning bell
Source: an original fiction extract.
The first sound came from below the quarry wall: three knocks, then nothing. I was alone in the gate hut, checking the chain against the closing list. Through the narrow window I could see the lower track, pale with dust. A dark shape lay beside the old loading platform. It might have been a coat. It might have been a heap of canvas left from the work crews.
I stepped outside and called down. The wind took my voice across the empty pit. On the track, two marks crossed the dust and stopped at the platform. They looked like footprints until I noticed how sharply they ended. The quarry foreman, Mr Bell, had told me that loose sheets sometimes slid from the storage shed. He had also told me never to assume the lower track was empty just because nobody answered.
I went back into the hut and checked the board. The last inspection, written in blue pencil, was marked 4.10. Under it, in a different hand, someone had added: CHECK LOWER GATE. No name, no time. I had seen the note earlier and thought it was old. Now I could not remember whether I had checked the lower gate or merely meant to. I tried to picture myself doing it. The picture kept changing: my hand on the latch, then my hand reaching for the keys.
The warning bell hung outside the hut. It was meant to be rung if anyone might be in the quarry after closing. Mr Bell had said that a false alarm would bring everyone back across the ridge for nothing. He had said, too, that the bell was there because once, years ago, someone had been left below after dark. I took hold of the rope, then let it go. I listened for another knock. The silence seemed to make both choices worse.
At last I rang. The sound travelled farther than I expected, striking the quarry walls and returning thinner. I rang again, because one ring might have been mistaken for the wind. Then I stood beside the gate and waited, watching the lower track. Nothing moved. When Mr Bell arrived with two workers, I showed him the marks and the note. He looked at the platform, then at me.
‘You saw someone?’ he asked.
‘No,’ I said. ‘I thought there might be someone.’
One of the workers followed the marks down to the platform. The dark shape was a sheet of canvas, folded over a stack of boards. The marks ended where its loose edge had dragged across the dust. The lower gate was shut. Mr Bell checked it twice, then asked why I had rung before checking the track from the upper path. I had not known there was a view from there. He did not raise his voice. That made it harder to answer.
The next morning, I read the closing list again. The blue-pencil note was still there, and I still could not say who had written it. I had tied the bell rope back on its hook, but I could still hear the second note in the quiet of the hut. I told myself I had acted on the evidence I had. Then I remembered how quickly I had imagined the report Mr Bell might write if someone had been left below. I could not decide whether that thought had made me careful, or merely afraid of being the person who had to explain what happened.
A reader argues that the narrator’s decision to ring the warning bell was cautious rather than an overreaction. Evaluate how convincing you find this view. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.