The cue cards
Source: an original fiction extract.
By the time Lila came home, Noah had arranged fourteen cue cards across the dining table. She had asked him that morning to listen to her school council speech once. He had agreed, but then he had found her folded draft beside the fruit bowl and decided that listening would not be enough. He copied each paragraph in block capitals, divided long sentences and added instructions in green pen: BREATHE. SLOW DOWN. LOOK UP.
Last term, Lila had forgotten her words while reading to the class. Noah could still picture her staring at the floor while somebody at the back whispered. Tomorrow would be different. He placed the cards in a straight line and moved the final one until its edge matched the others exactly.
The front door opened. Lila entered with rain shining on her hair and began, ‘Maya won’t be—’
‘Perfect timing,’ Noah said. ‘I’ve finished.’
He pointed to the first card. Lila put down her bag but remained standing. She read the opening sentence.
‘Slower,’ he said. ‘And you missed the pause.’
She began again. After six words, Noah tapped the instruction in green pen. Lila stopped. Her thumb rubbed backwards and forwards along the edge of the card.
‘Can I tell you what happened today?’ she asked.
‘After one complete practice,’ Noah replied. ‘Otherwise we’ll lose our place.’
On the third card, Lila used a word from her original draft instead of the one Noah had written. He corrected her. On the fifth, she fell silent altogether. Noah supplied the next sentence, but she pushed the cards towards him and went into the kitchen. A moment later, he heard the tap running.
Noah gathered the cards into a neat pile. Underneath them lay Lila’s original speech. The writing sloped uphill, and several sentences had been squeezed into the margins. Near the bottom, she had written: MAYA’S PART. Noah looked towards the kitchen and remembered the unfinished words at the door.
He found Lila standing beside the sink without a glass. ‘What happened to Maya?’ he asked.
Lila explained that Maya, who was meant to share the speech, had been sent home ill. Their teacher had asked Lila to present alone. ‘I didn’t need a different speech,’ she said. ‘I needed to know whether mine still worked with only one person.’
Noah put his green pen in his pocket. This time, when Lila spoke, he did not interrupt. He listened until she reached the section marked MAYA’S PART, then asked which ideas she wanted to keep. Together, they crossed out two repeated points. Lila chose three of Noah’s cue cards and copied her own words onto them.
They practised in the hallway, with Noah sitting halfway up the stairs as the audience. When Lila paused, he waited. After a few seconds, she found the next line herself.
Before they finished, Noah wrote a message on a spare card and gave it to her: IF YOU GET STUCK, LOOK AT ME. I’LL WAIT. Lila placed it behind the other three. The cards were different sizes and their edges did not meet. Noah noticed, but left them as they were.
After reading the whole source, one student commented:
“The writer uses the cue cards to show how Noah changes: at first they show his need to control Lila’s speech, but by the end they show that he trusts her.”
Evaluate this view.
You could write about:
Support your response with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.