The team list
Source: an original fiction extract.
Leah wrote the four names on the classroom whiteboard before anyone else arrived. The headteacher had asked her to put together a team for the inter-school quiz, and the four pupils she had chosen were quick, confident and, conveniently, her closest friends. By morning break, they were already discussing what snacks to take and whether the school would let them miss lessons to practise. Suki drew a trophy beside the names. Leah left it there.
That evening, Leah spread a set of practice questions across the kitchen table. Her older brother Tom stopped behind her chair and read the team list at the top of the page.
‘When did you hold the trials?’ he asked.
Leah looked up. ‘I didn’t need trials. I know who’s good.’
Tom picked up a question sheet. ‘Do you know everyone in your year?’
‘Enough of them.’
‘Then is this the best team for the school, or the best team for sitting with you at lunch?’
Heat rose into Leah’s face. She snatched the sheet from him and told him he always turned simple things into problems. Tom did not apologise, but he did not suggest any names either. He said he had no idea who should be on the team. He only wondered how anyone outside Leah’s group was supposed to know that there had been a chance to join it. Then he went upstairs, leaving Leah with four familiar names that suddenly seemed much larger on the page.
The next morning, Leah stood beside the whiteboard while her friends waited for her to begin the first practice. Her announcement came out more quietly than she intended. There would be a short trial at lunchtime, she explained, and anyone in the year could enter.
‘But you’ve already chosen us,’ Suki said, pointing at the board.
Leah reached for the cloth. ‘That was a draft.’
The trophy disappeared first. The names took longer.
At lunchtime, twelve pupils arrived. Leah gave each of them a numbered answer sheet so that she could mark the responses without seeing anyone’s name. Dylan, one of her original choices, finished early and leaned back with a grin. Rohan, who rarely spoke in class, remained bent over his paper until the final second. When Leah marked the answers, Dylan had left six spaces blank. Rohan had achieved the highest score. Two of Leah’s friends were in the top four, but Suki was fifth, one point behind Amara.
Leah added the scores again. For a moment, she considered including a question about teamwork and holding another round. Suki was excellent at encouraging people, after all. Yet the rules had not mentioned a second round, and changing them now would look like changing them for one person. Leah wrote the four highest-scoring names on a clean sheet of paper.
Suki read the list without speaking. Her disappointment made Leah want to explain everything at once, but instead Leah said that all twelve pupils could attend the practice sessions and that the reserves would be chosen from those sessions using rules published in advance. Suki gave a small shrug and walked away. Leah did not feel victorious.
At home, Tom asked whether she had found a good team. Leah thought of the numbered papers, Suki’s face and Rohan’s surprised smile when he saw his name.
‘I think so,’ she said.
Tom nodded. ‘Then it was worth finding out.’
The following morning, Leah pinned the new list to the noticeboard. Underneath it, she added the trial scores and the arrangements for practice. Her writing was smaller than it had been on the whiteboard, but every name was clear.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Tom’s questions shake Leah’s confidence, but they help her choose the quiz team in a fairer way.”
Evaluate how far you agree.
In your response, you could:
Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.