The scattered seedlings
Source: an original fiction extract.
Sam had wheeled the seed tray across the community garden on a small trolley. Near the gate, a wheel caught on a stone. The tray tipped. Small pots rolled across the path, and dark compost spilled over Sam’s shoes.
‘I’ve ruined them,’ Sam said. He crouched to gather the pots, trying to keep the seedlings upright. A few leaves had been pressed into the soil. Behind him, the garden’s open day was already under way; people were arriving with cups of tea and folded chairs.
Mrs Iqbal, who looked after the plot beside Sam’s, came over with an empty crate. She did not tell him it was all right. Instead, she held the crate steady while he lifted the pots into it. ‘This one’s still standing,’ she said, pointing to a seedling with two leaves stretched towards the light.
They worked along the path together. Sam brushed soil from each pot and Mrs Iqbal checked the stems. When they reached the last one, she showed him how to press the loose compost back around its roots. ‘My first lot looked worse than this,’ she said. ‘I planted them too close to the edge of the bench, and the wind got underneath.’
Sam glanced at the rows of plants on her plot. He had thought she always knew exactly what she was doing. ‘Did they grow?’ he asked.
‘Some did,’ she said. ‘Some didn’t.’ She lifted the crate, and he took the other side. They carried the seedlings to the sheltered table by the greenhouse. There was room beside her own trays.
By the time the visitors reached them, Sam had lined the pots up again. One was leaning, but its leaves were still intact. Mrs Iqbal handed him a bundle of labels. Sam wrote his name on one, then paused and added hers beneath it.
‘You don’t have to put my name,’ she said.
‘You helped,’ Sam replied. He looked at the soil on his shoes. It was still a mess, and the seedlings were not as neat as before. But he no longer wished the morning had gone differently. Before she turned back to her own trays, he asked if she would show him how to build a cover for the table before the next windy day.
A reader said: “At first, Sam sees the accident as a disaster, but by the end he understands that it has given him a chance to learn from Mrs Iqbal.”
Evaluate how far you agree with this statement. In your answer, you could consider Sam’s reactions at the beginning and end, and how the writer presents his relationship with Mrs Iqbal. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.