The blue bowl
Source: an original fiction extract.
By noon, the kitchen no longer looked like a room. Cupboards stood open and empty, chairs were stacked in the hallway and brown boxes covered most of the floor. On the windowsill, away from the confusion, stood a blue china bowl. Leila's mother had lined a small carton with an old jumper and written BLUE BOWL - FRONT SEAT across the lid. The bowl had belonged to Leila's grandmother, and her mother intended to carry it to the new house herself.
Leila was sealing the last box of mugs when the tape tore. The spare roll was behind the bowl. She reached across the sill, caught the rim with her sleeve and heard china strike the tiles. Once. Then again.
For a moment, she did not move. A curved blue piece spun beneath the table and settled by her shoe. Her mother was upstairs, calling instructions to the removal men. Leila imagined her coming through the door and seeing the fragments. She gathered them into a sheet of newspaper, folded it tightly and pushed the bundle deep into the outside bin. When she returned, the bare patch on the windowsill seemed brighter than the rest of the room.
Ten minutes later, her mother came downstairs. “Where's the bowl?”
Leila pressed the loose end of the tape against the box. “I haven't seen it.”
Her mother checked the windowsill, then opened the boxes nearest the door. “Did you move it?”
Leila shook her head. She had expected the lie to end the conversation. Instead, it seemed to make the room busier. Her mother searched between layers of newspaper, unpacking cups that had already been wrapped. One of the removal men called from the front step to say that the van was ready.
“I must have put it somewhere,” her mother said. She opened another box.
Through the window, Leila saw the bin lorry stop outside. Two workers rolled the bin towards it. She could have spoken then. She watched the bin rise, tip and fall back empty. The lorry moved on.
Her mother was kneeling beside a box, surrounded by cups and crumpled paper. “We'll have to go without it,” she said quietly.
Leila's mouth felt dry. “You didn't lose it.”
Her mother looked up.
“I broke it,” Leila said. “It was an accident. I put it in the bin before you started looking.”
Neither of them spoke for several seconds. Her mother looked towards the window, although the lorry had already turned the corner. Then she stood and closed the box she had been searching.
Beside the front door, the little carton marked BLUE BOWL - FRONT SEAT was still waiting. Leila's mother picked up the marker pen and held it out to her. Leila drew one firm line through the label. She did not scribble over the words. They remained visible beneath the ink.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Leila's panic after breaking the bowl is understandable, but hiding what she has done makes the situation worse. Her confession at the end shows real courage, even though it comes too late to save the bowl.”
Evaluate how far you agree.
In your response, you could consider:
Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer's methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.