The replacement tree
Source: an original fiction extract.
The replacement tree stood in the exact centre of the square, held upright by two polished stakes. Its branches were thin and evenly spaced, as if somebody had arranged them before the ceremony. Nadia decided that it looked too obedient. Beside the platform, she placed the bucket containing her own tree: a crooked cutting, no higher than her knee, taken from the old pear before the storm finished splitting its trunk. A ribbon had been tied around the bucket handle, although she had not asked for one.
When the council first announced that the damaged tree would be removed, Nadia had printed five hundred leaflets. SAVE OUR CENTURY-OLD PEAR, they said above a photograph of its broad summer branches. Her grandmother had always claimed that the tree had been there for a hundred years, and Nadia had repeated the claim at meetings until it sounded like a fact she had personally checked. Later, in the town archive, she found a record dated sixty-eight years before the ceremony, showing that six residents had planted the pear after the great flood. Her grandmother’s was the third name on the list. Nadia folded the record into her notebook. Sixty-eight years did not make the tree less important, she told herself, so there was no need to alter the remaining leaflets.
Mr Hart from the council had inspected Nadia’s cutting and called it promising. However, he said that the square needed a larger tree, one that could survive footballs, bicycles and summer crowds. The cutting could be planted in the courtyard of the community centre, where volunteers would look after it. Nadia heard the offer as an instruction to put history somewhere it would not inconvenience anyone. She had prepared a speech about roots and memory, but the council had not asked her to deliver it. Instead, they had invited her to remove the cloth from the new plaque.
The council chair thanked Nadia for making sure that a tree would remain at the heart of the square. When the cloth fell away, the plaque described how six local residents had planted the old pear after the flood and how the new tree would continue that tradition. There was no mention of a century. Nadia became aware of the unused speech in her coat pocket. During the applause, an elderly woman beside her traced one of the names on the plaque with a gloved finger. ‘I carried water here for that tree when I was a girl,’ she said. ‘We all thought it would die in its first winter.’
A reporter asked Nadia whether the new tree was what she had hoped for. ‘No,’ Nadia began. Then she saw three children taking turns to find names on the plaque while their father read the flood story aloud. Behind them, Mr Hart was showing two volunteers where to leave space around the trunk. ‘Not exactly,’ she said, and asked the reporter to photograph the cutting as well.
That afternoon, Nadia planted it in the community-centre courtyard with a group of children. She gave them the archive record and asked what its label should say. One child wrote, GROWN FROM THE OLD PEAR. Another added, THE OLD PEAR WAS PLANTED BY SIX NEIGHBOURS AFTER THE FLOOD. The courtyard was not the square, but people stopped to read both sentences on their way inside. Before leaving, Nadia unwound the ceremony ribbon from the bucket handle. She tied it loosely to the cutting’s stake, checking that it could not tighten around the growing stem.
Read the whole source.
One interpretation is: “Nadia first sees the council’s choice as an attempt to erase the past. By the end, the writer has exposed the limits of Nadia’s own account of that past, but still presents her campaign as necessary.”
Evaluate this interpretation. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.