The sea arch
Source: an original fiction extract.
From the beach, the sea arch had looked like a doorway cut into the headland. Now, with the kayaks rising and falling beneath it, the opening seemed less like a doorway than a mouth. Sunlight flashed on the water outside, but inside the rock there was only a shifting darkness and the hollow crash of waves.
Nell rested her paddle across the kayak and tried to loosen her grip. She had spent the walk from the minibus telling everyone that the cave would be the best part of the trip. When Yusuf had admitted that he was nervous, she had laughed and promised to tow him through herself. He was already several metres ahead of her now, following the instructor towards the entrance.
Before they had left the beach, the instructor had pointed to a yellow marker fixed beside the arch. If the waves rose high enough to hide it, he had said, they would turn back. At the time, the rule had seemed unnecessarily cautious. The marker was visible now, then gone behind a shoulder of grey water, then visible again.
“Keep together,” the instructor called.
The others closed the gaps between their kayaks. Nell paddled twice, but the second stroke barely touched the water. Her arms felt light and useless. She could hear the group talking ahead of her, their voices bouncing out of the cave in cheerful fragments. No one else appeared to be watching the marker.
A wave lifted Nell until she could see directly into the arch. For a moment, the roof seemed lower than before. Water struck the rock inside and returned in a white rush. She remembered the instructor saying that turning a group around was easier before the entrance than after it.
“Wait,” she called.
Yusuf looked over his shoulder. “You were the one who wanted to do this.”
A few of the others laughed. The sound was small against the rock, but Nell felt it land. She imagined them repeating the story later: Nell boasting on the beach, Nell freezing when the cave was in front of her. Her face became hot despite the cold spray.
The instructor allowed his kayak to drift back towards her. “Are you all right?”
Nell could have blamed the fastening on her life jacket or said that her paddle felt loose. Both excuses arrived complete in her mind. Instead, she pointed towards the arch. The yellow marker had vanished again, this time for several seconds.
“I’m asking us to turn back,” she said.
The instructor looked at the marker, then at the line of kayaks. He did not answer immediately. That pause was worse than the laughter. Nell’s kayak swung sideways, and she corrected it with a clumsy stroke.
“Back to the beach,” he called at last.
No one argued with him, but the return journey was quiet. Yusuf paddled past Nell without looking at her. She followed the instructor’s red kayak and counted each stroke. The arch grew smaller behind them until it became a neat black shape in the cliff once more.
They had almost reached the beach when a sound like a heavy door slamming travelled across the water. Nell turned. A wave had broken against the headland, filling the arch from wall to wall with white water. Spray rose above the rock and hung there before falling.
On the sand, Yusuf said, “We might have been through by then.”
“We might,” the instructor replied. “Or we might not.” He began pulling the kayaks beyond the reach of the waves. “That is why the marker is there.”
Nell climbed out unsteadily. Her knees were shaking, and there was no satisfaction in discovering this. She took hold of the nearest kayak and helped drag it up the beach. After a moment, Yusuf lifted the other end. Neither of them mentioned the cave.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “Nell’s fear does not make her weak. By turning back when everyone expects her to continue, she shows more courage than the others.” Evaluate how far you agree with this view. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.