The shortlisted story
Source: an original fiction extract.
Mariam was checking the final shortlist when she recognised the sentence. It appeared halfway down the third page of Caleb’s story, between a description of an empty road and a paragraph about rain. She read it again, then turned to the next page. Two more sentences were familiar. She had read them aloud from an old anthology during a library event the previous winter.
Around her, the competition room was being prepared for the announcement. Six certificates lay across the front table, and somebody had arranged paper cups beside a jug of orange squash. Caleb’s name was written on the certificate for first place. Mariam covered it with her hand while she compared his story with the anthology. The wording was exact.
She found Caleb in the corridor, practising the beginning of his acceptance speech under his breath. At first, he laughed when she showed him the pages. Then his face changed. He said the opening had been difficult and that he had only borrowed a few lines to get started. Everything else was his. Mariam asked him to withdraw before the announcement.
‘Over three sentences?’ he said. ‘You’ve known me since primary school.’
‘That’s why I’m asking you first.’
Caleb folded the copied pages and pushed them into her hand. He said that the judges had already chosen and that nobody would ever notice. Then he asked whether rules mattered more to her than people. When Mariam did not answer, he walked back into the competition room and took a seat beside the other finalists.
The organiser, Ms Dean, was testing the microphone when Mariam approached her. Mariam spoke quietly and gave her both texts. She had expected Ms Dean to look shocked, but the organiser only removed her glasses, read the pages and asked Mariam to wait outside.
The announcement began fifteen minutes late. Ms Dean told the audience that one entry had been withdrawn and that the judges needed more time before awarding first place. Caleb remained in his seat until everyone else had gone. As Mariam stacked the unused cups, she heard him tell another finalist that somebody had decided to make trouble. He did not look towards her.
Ms Dean thanked Mariam for protecting the fairness of the competition. The sentence sounded polished, as if it belonged in an email. It did not help when two other students stopped talking as Mariam entered the library. By the end of the afternoon, everybody seemed to know what had happened, although Mariam had told only Caleb and Ms Dean.
That evening, Caleb sent her a single message: ‘I hope the rules keep you company.’ Mariam began several replies. In one, she accused him of placing her in an impossible position. In another, she apologised. She deleted them all and left the message unanswered.
At the next magazine meeting, Caleb’s usual chair remained empty. Mariam placed the proof pages around the table and noticed that a new contributor’s name had been left off the contents page. Correcting it would delay the printer again. She wrote the missing name in the margin, circled it twice and carried the pages back to Ms Dean. Before leaving, she put a copy of the magazine on the empty chair. She did not know whether Caleb would return for it.
Consider the whole source. A reader said: “By the end of the story, the writer has made us share Caleb’s view that Mariam cares more about rules than about people.” Evaluate how far you agree. Support your judgement with detailed references to the text and the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.