Maya had only returned to the residents’ lounge in her block of flats for her coat. The evening class there had ended an hour earlier, and the ground floor should have been empty, but a light still burned above the basement stairs. Halfway down, she heard water striking the floor with a quick, steady rhythm.
A shining line had crept beneath the utility-room door. Maya stopped. That afternoon, she had put the paint rollers in a bucket beneath the tap. Someone had called from upstairs about a missing set of keys, and she had left the bucket filling. She remembered deciding that she would be back before it reached the top. She also remembered the blue cloth lying across the sink’s drain.
When she opened the door, water was pouring over the bucket’s rim. It had already crossed the utility room and entered the basement corridor where the residents’ storage cages stood. Maya shut off the tap and dragged the cloth from the drain. For a moment, she considered going upstairs to telephone the building manager. Then she saw the dark water touching the bottom of the cardboard boxes in cage fourteen. If she moved them quickly, perhaps the whole incident could remain small enough to explain.
The padlock on cage fourteen was hanging open. Mr Nadeem appeared on the stairs as Maya lifted the first box onto a dry shelf. He had come to collect a suitcase for his daughter. When he saw the water, he gripped the handrail and asked what had happened.
‘The sink overflowed,’ Maya said. ‘Stay there. The floor’s slippery.’
He ignored her and stepped down. Maya told him more sharply to stop, then carried two boxes towards him. One was marked TOOLS. The other had MUM’S LETTERS written across its lid in faded ink. Its damp cardboard bent beneath her fingers. Mr Nadeem reached for it, but Maya turned away from him and placed it on the stairs herself.
More water was entering the cage. Maya’s trainers filled as she returned for the remaining boxes. One split when she lifted it, spilling envelopes across the floor. She dropped to her knees and gathered them against her jumper. The ink on several addresses had begun to spread. Mr Nadeem called down that she should leave them, but she continued until every envelope was balanced on the step above the water.
The building manager arrived carrying a mop and a ring of keys. He stared at the flooded corridor, then at Maya’s soaked clothes. ‘Do you know how this started?’ he asked.
Maya looked towards the utility room. ‘The tap was running when I came down.’ The sentence fitted the facts as neatly as a lid. Before the manager could ask anything else, Mr Nadeem said that Maya had saved nearly everything. He called her brave. She concentrated on pressing the loose flap back onto the box of letters.
The manager returned from the utility room holding the blue cloth between two fingers. A streak of yellow paint crossed one corner. He asked whether it belonged to the afternoon class.
Mr Nadeem lifted the box of letters, but his hands were shaking. Maya took it from him. The wet cardboard sagged against her arms.
‘Let me carry this upstairs first,’ she said.
The manager repeated his question. Maya tightened her grip on the box and began to climb. It was neither an answer nor a refusal.
Focus on the whole of this source.
A reader said: ‘Maya’s actions are brave, but she is mainly trying to protect herself from blame. By the end, however, the writer makes her silence more difficult to judge.’
To what extent do you agree and/or disagree? Evaluate how the writer first exposes Maya’s responsibility and then complicates the reader’s judgement of her, using evidence and analysis of the writer’s methods.
407 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 5.2 Content, covering 5.2.1 Reading source: literature fiction text, 5.2.2 Focus of the extracts, 5.2.3 Stimulus for students' own writing, and 5.2.4 Scenario sets audience, purpose and form. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.