Text One: The fountain on the corner
An original personal account by a resident.
For years, the fountain at the corner of Market Street was a place I passed without seeing. Its basin had turned the colour of old coins, and a notice on the wall advised people not to use it. When the council announced that it would be repaired, I assumed the result would be a new fountain, bright and obedient, like one in a town-centre photograph.
Instead, the first thing I noticed was the uneven stone around its base. A mason had left it in place, and the new pipework could not be seen from the pavement. The fountain did not look new. It looked as though somebody had paid attention.
I had expected the work to be measured by how quickly the water returned. The temporary barrier stayed up for another week while the team checked the flow and cleaned the basin. I grumbled about the delay, until I saw a child try the handle and get nothing but a cough of air. The extra days were doing a job I had not thought to ask about.
Now I stop there on my way to the bus. The water is not a grand attraction, and nobody has put up a sign telling us to admire it. But people use it: a runner fills a bottle; a market seller rinses a dusty apple. I have started to value the small things a repair makes possible, not just the moment when a barrier comes down.
Text Two: Repair is more than replacement
An original article by a council maintenance worker.
When people ask why a fountain takes weeks to reopen, they usually mean the visible part of the job. The stone has been cleaned; the handle turns; surely that is enough. Yet a working public fountain depends on parts that most passers-by will never see, and on checks that cannot be rushed simply to make a site look finished.
At Market Street, we kept the old basin because it was sound, then fitted new pipework behind it. That choice meant working around a structure rather than clearing the whole site. It took longer, but it kept a familiar feature of the street and avoided replacing material that still had a use.
A barrier can give the impression that nothing is happening. In fact, some of the most important work is quiet: checking that the water runs as it should, cleaning the basin, and making sure the handle works reliably. We need to explain this better. If all people see is a closed space, a careful repair can look like a delay without a reason.
I do not think every old feature should be preserved simply because it is old. Sometimes replacement is the sensible answer. But repair deserves to be judged by what it allows a place to keep doing, as well as by how quickly the work is completed. A fountain is useful when people can trust it enough to use it.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about repairing and using public places.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.