The hours of the bell
Text One: Do not silence the square
An original letter by a long-term resident opposing a proposal to stop the town-hall bell sounding overnight.
The council notice uses the phrase “suspended between 11 p.m. and 7 a.m.” Suspended is a neat, bloodless word. It makes eight hours of silence sound like a minor administrative adjustment, as if the town could simply pause one of its habits and collect it again after breakfast.
I will not pretend that the bell is beautiful on every occasion. In wet weather, its note seems to drop heavily into the square. Sometimes it interrupts a conversation or announces an hour I would rather not know. But public sounds do not exist only to please us. The bell has never been a private performance; it is one of the ways the town makes its presence felt.
When I was seventeen and walking home late from my first job, I listened for it. The shops were shuttered and the bus station was empty, but the bell made the square seem attended. Years later, during a power cut, it stopped. I woke before dawn and knew something was wrong before I remembered why. The town had not become peaceful. It had mislaid its pulse.
Supporters of the proposal say that nobody needs to be told the time during the night. That reduces the bell to a speaking clock. It also assumes that night belongs only to people asleep behind closed windows. Bakers begin work, cleaners finish it and late buses still cross the square. Their town should not disappear merely because most of us have gone to bed.
Of course, complaints should be investigated. The mechanism could be checked and the force of the strike reduced. A tradition which refuses every adjustment becomes stubbornness. Yet adjustment is different from switching the bell off for a third of each day. Keeping the metal in the tower while removing its voice would preserve an object, not a living custom.
The bell is occasionally inconvenient because shared places are occasionally inconvenient. They interrupt the private worlds we build around ourselves. That is not always a fault. Before we congratulate ourselves on creating peace, we should ask whose idea of peace it is.
Text Two: Eight quiet hours
An original article by a resident supporting the proposal to stop the town-hall bell sounding overnight.
At three in the morning, the bell does not make me feel part of a community. It enters the bedroom, strikes the glass of water beside the bed and leaves me waiting for the next quarter-hour. Once I have heard it, I begin listening against my will. The sound ends; the interruption does not.
Defenders of the bell often call it the town’s “heartbeat”. The comparison is attractive, but a heartbeat is contained within the body it serves. This noise travels through other people’s ceilings and expects them to treat disturbance as affection. Those who sleep through it can enjoy the idea of the bell without experiencing its cost.
I like hearing it on market mornings. Then its notes mix with delivery trolleys, greetings and the opening of stalls. On festival days, it gives the square a sense of occasion. Context changes sound: what is cheerful at noon can be exhausting in darkness. Recognising that difference is not an attack on the town’s character.
Nor is anyone proposing that the bell should be melted down or hidden in a museum. It could continue during the day and mark public ceremonies. The argument is about hours, not existence. We already decide when the town hall opens, when roadworks may begin and when events in the square must finish. A tradition can have a timetable without becoming false.
The language used by opponents also troubles me. They speak as though silence were an empty space and noise were proof of life. Yet the square is surrounded by homes. Night workers return to them; children sleep in them; elderly neighbours live in them. These residents are no less part of the town than the people who admire the tower from a daytime café.
Reducing the volume would help, but it would still leave the bell deciding when thousands of private nights should be interrupted. Let it speak when the square is awake enough to answer. Eight quiet hours would not erase our history. They would show that a town can value what it has inherited without requiring its residents to hear it at every moment.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about whether the town-hall bell should sound through the night.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.