Practising for the flood
Text One: The day the timetable failed
An original account by the coordinator of a community flood exercise.
My plan divided the morning into twelve-minute sections. Volunteers were arranged into coloured teams; messages were numbered; even the arrival of the imaginary flood had a time beside it. I wanted the exercise to demonstrate that we were prepared, and preparation, on my clipboard, looked remarkably like punctuality.
At 9.18, an observer handed me a card announcing that the footbridge was unavailable. The bridge appeared in nearly every route I had written. My first instinct was to pause the exercise, move the obstacle somewhere less destructive and allow the timetable to recover. Instead, I put the card on the table and said nothing.
The red team immediately chose the longer road. The blue team waited for my permission. The green team continued carrying supplies towards the bridge because nobody had told them that the route had changed. Within minutes, my orderly exercise had become three different exercises.
By the standards I had set, the morning was failing. Yet the delay revealed more than a smooth performance would have done. One radio message referred simply to ‘the hall’, although our neighbourhood has two. Several volunteers knew only their own task and could not explain its purpose. Others possessed useful local knowledge but assumed that the plan had already accounted for it.
At the debrief, I was tempted to describe the disruption as a minor difficulty before returning to the successes. That would have protected the exercise rather than improved our preparation. We did not need another morning in which everybody proved that they could follow instructions under perfect conditions.
The revised plan will contain clearer priorities but fewer directions. Teams will practise changing roles, and the coordinator will not answer every question. A timetable can organise a morning. It cannot certify that a community is ready for uncertainty.
Text Two: Waiting for an answer
An original reflection by a resident who volunteered in the exercise.
The yellow vest was too large, the pavement was dry and the ‘flood water’ was a strip of blue tape. I found it difficult to take the exercise seriously. My card instructed me to check three addresses and report to the community centre. Nothing on it suggested that I might have to think.
Then we were told that the footbridge could not be used. I assumed this was an unnecessary piece of theatre added to make the morning more exciting. Our team called the coordinator, but no answer came. For several minutes, five adults stood beside a perfectly usable bridge because a piece of card had forbidden us to cross it.
Once we began discussing alternatives, the neat instructions became less important. One volunteer knew that the alley on the map was too narrow for our trolley. Another pointed out that taking the longer road would leave nobody at the registration desk. I had lived nearby for nine years without knowing either fact.
We eventually reached the community centre late. The person acting as a stranded resident then asked why we had checked her house but not the neighbouring bungalow. None of us knew whether that responsibility belonged to our team. The moment felt more uncomfortable than the blocked bridge because it exposed a question we had not thought to ask.
I do not believe that every confusion should be celebrated as valuable. Some instructions were simply unclear, and unclear instructions can be rewritten. Nor did a sunny rehearsal reproduce the fear or urgency of a real flood. However, the exercise showed how quickly I searched for somebody in charge when the written answer disappeared.
By the end, the blue tape still looked ridiculous, but the people around it did not. I had heard knowledge that was absent from my card and questions that were absent from the official plan. I still want a plan in my hand. I no longer want it to silence the person beside me.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about plans and uncertainty in the flood exercise.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.