What belongs in the gap?
Text One: The bowl with a white side
An original account by a museum conservator preparing an excavated bowl for display.
At my workbench, the bowl did not look like an object awaiting repair. It was nine pieces of brown clay in a shallow tray. Three carried part of the rim; one showed the tail of a blue-painted fish. Laid apart, they seemed to have no obligation to one another.
The curator first suggested displaying the fragments on dark cloth. Nothing would be added and no visitor could mistake the result for an undamaged bowl. I arranged them carefully, then invited a colleague from another department to look. She admired the fish and asked what the other pieces were. I realised that our cautious display required visitors to perform work for which we had quietly kept all the clues.
I joined the fragments that fitted and made a smooth white support for the missing section. It carried the curve from the surviving base to the rim but did not continue the painted design. A colleague wondered whether the white could be coloured brown so that it attracted less attention. That would certainly have made the bowl easier on the eye. It would also have allowed the eye to pass over every modern decision as though no decision had been made.
When the bowl entered the gallery, one visitor called it unfinished. Another stood back until the outline became clear, then moved close enough to examine the breaks. During a school visit, a pupil pointed at the white section and announced, “That part is fake.” The word stung, although it was not entirely wrong. The support was false if it claimed to be ancient clay; it was truthful if it worked like a sentence printed in another typeface.
A second pupil wanted to know whether the blue fish had continued across the missing area. I could not answer. The white surface gave her room to ask without supplying an invented fish.
From the gallery doorway, the object offered the shape of a bowl. At close range, it withdrew that certainty piece by piece. I had not returned it to an earlier condition. I had made an argument about its shape and left the joins where the argument could be examined.
Text Two: The life that arrived whole
An original personal essay by a writer researching a relative for a family-history booklet.
My great-aunt Nora’s life reached me in a paragraph repeated at family gatherings. She had run the family guest house alone, trusted nobody’s advice and fed any traveller who could not pay. Different relatives changed the order of these claims, but never their certainty.
I was asked to write about Nora for a booklet marking one hundred years since her birth. There was a photograph of her behind the reception desk, several pages of accounts in her handwriting and a letter to her brother asking, “What price did we agree for the upstairs rooms?” These traces proved that she had worked there. They did not tell me whether she worked alone, ignored advice or offered free meals.
My first draft solved the problem too eagerly. I placed Nora at the desk during a storm, listening to the wind while a penniless stranger waited outside. The scene was vivid because I had supplied nearly all of it. I deleted the rain, the stranger and even the time of day.
Then I retreated into a list of dates. It looked responsible but produced a different distortion. The years for which no document survived appeared empty, while an ordinary Tuesday preserved in the account book acquired enormous importance. Evidence had not selected the significant moments of Nora’s life; chance had selected the evidence.
Two elderly cousins offered further help. One remembered Nora quietly giving a family supper when their money ran out. The other remembered her refusing credit to a guest. Each cousin presented a complete character: generous Nora or hard Nora. I kept both incidents. People are not required to remain consistent merely to make a booklet easier to organise.
In the final version, I wrote that Nora managed the accounts and may have taken wider responsibility for the guest house. The letter showed consultation with her brother, not obedience to him. The cousins’ memories appeared beside their names rather than being blended into one confident voice.
A relative reading the booklet asked, “But what was she really like?” I understood the disappointment. A story usually promises that scattered details will become a person. Mine made the distance between the details more visible. The gaps remained, but they no longer belonged automatically to whoever told the story loudest.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about making sense of incomplete evidence.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.