The rain that missed us
Text One: A forecast for a decision
An original column by a weekend walker.
The forecast showed a dark cloud precisely where our picnic was supposed to happen. We moved the food indoors. At two, sunlight filled the garden with the self-satisfaction of a guest who had arrived after an argument about whether to invite him.
For several minutes I was cross with the weather service. It had apparently borrowed the afternoon and returned it in an inconveniently different condition. Then I read the words beneath the symbol. They had never promised that rain would arrive at my table. I had converted a possibility into an instruction and was now annoyed at being obeyed by neither.
This does not make the forecast useless. We need some way of deciding what to carry, where to meet and whether an outdoor plan has a sensible alternative. But a small picture on a screen is remarkably good at becoming the whole sky in my head.
The following week, I looked at more than the icon. I considered the timing, read the explanation and left a coat by the door. The picnic went ahead. We moved under a tree for a short shower and returned to the table afterwards. Nobody demanded a verdict on whether the forecast had been right.
I still want useful information, not an elegant excuse for any outcome. I also suspect that usefulness sometimes asks more of me than choosing the most convenient symbol. A forecast cannot make the day certain. It may help me make a plan which does not require certainty in order to survive.
Text Two: Why the wording matters
An original article by a weather presenter.
After a dry afternoon, a viewer writes to ask why we mentioned showers. After a wet one, another asks why we did not sound more definite. Both want advice they can use, and neither deserves a reply which treats disappointment as evidence that they failed an examination in probability.
Our task is to explain what may happen clearly enough for people to make decisions. That requires more than placing a symbol over a place name. A map can look exact even when the situation it describes is unsettled. The certainty of the drawing must not quietly become a certainty we have not earned.
I read scripts aloud before broadcasting. Words which seem careful on a page can sound evasive in a hurried sentence. Words which sound reassuring can make a possibility disappear. We discuss examples of how a change might affect an ordinary plan, without pretending that everyone will make the same choice.
There is a temptation to defend every forecast by pointing to a phrase somewhere in the explanation. Technically, the phrase may be there. Communication has still failed if most viewers reasonably understood something else. Accuracy includes being clear about what the information does and does not say.
I cannot offer a forecast with no uncertainty. I can offer a clearer account of it and admit when an account was poor. The aim is not to win the argument after the rain. It is to give people something useful before they step outside.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about using and communicating weather forecasts.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.