Text One: Three hours without through traffic
An original article by a resident who coordinates a weekly play street.
At two o’clock on Sunday, the red barriers go across our road and its surface changes character. Chalk islands spread between the kerbs. A skipping rope marks out its own territory. Children who usually disappear behind separate front doors begin inventing rules for a game that did not exist five minutes earlier.
During the other 165 hours of the week, the road is organised mainly for vehicles. Cars occupy both sides, engines decide when conversation must pause and crossing from one pavement to the other requires attention. Our scheme does not claim that these uses can vanish. It asks whether they must dominate every hour.
The idea grew from an ordinary residents’ meeting rather than a grand theory about childhood. Parents wanted somewhere nearby for younger children; several older neighbours wanted more contact with the families living around them. We agreed to try one afternoon and review it afterwards. The trial became a regular event because residents kept volunteering to run it.
Preparation is less visible than the games. Dates are circulated in advance, volunteers stand at both ends and a clear route is kept for residents’ vehicles and essential access. Drivers are guided through at walking pace. These arrangements do not spoil the freedom of the afternoon; they prevent that freedom from depending on confusion.
Critics sometimes describe the scheme as though the road has been seized. Yet a place can serve more than one purpose without being stolen from anyone. On play-street afternoons, teenagers repair scooters beside children drawing castles, while adults bring chairs to the pavement. Participation is not measured by how energetically someone joins in. Watching, talking or opening a window to hear the activity can also be a way of belonging.
Three hours of play will not solve every problem caused by traffic, and this arrangement would not suit every road. It does, however, remind us that a street can be a room as well as a route. The barriers are temporary; the recognition between neighbours may last longer.
Text Two: The appointment behind the barrier
An original opinion column by a home-care worker.
At 3.10 on Sunday afternoon, I turned into Rowan Street on my way to a client. A barrier blocked the road and the volunteer beside it was helping to settle an argument over a football. When I explained where I was going, she moved the barrier, asked several children to clear their scooters and guided my car forward. Four minutes passed before I reached the house.
Four minutes is not a disaster. It is also not nothing. Home-care visits are arranged one after another, and a delay at one address travels to the next. The person waiting indoors does not experience those minutes as part of a cheerful neighbourhood event. She experiences them as her worker arriving late.
The notice advertising the play street says that vehicle access is maintained. In the narrowest sense, it is: I eventually drove through. However, access that becomes available after an explanation, a search for the responsible volunteer and the removal of games is different from a route that is ready when it is needed. The wording describes permission, not reliability.
Some residents can avoid driving during the advertised hours, and families can decide whether to join the games. Other journeys are not so easily rearranged. Care workers, taxis collecting passengers and people making essential deliveries may have to arrive at a particular address at a particular time. Their work should not be treated as an interruption that matters only after the afternoon’s activities have been organised.
The purpose of the scheme is worth defending. Children need safe places to play, and neighbours benefit from meeting one another. Those aims should encourage better planning rather than silence practical criticism.
Keep a marked lane free instead of allowing games to spread across the full width of the road. Place one adult at each barrier whose first responsibility is access, and use equipment that can be moved immediately. These changes would leave plenty of space for play while making the promise of entry meaningful. A public event should be judged partly by how it treats people who are not attending it.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about a weekly play-street scheme.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.