A seat in the square
Text One: The bench we asked for
An original article by a resident campaigning for public seating.
The redesigned square has a fountain, a smooth pavement and a diagram explaining where people are expected to gather. It has no ordinary bench. There are three polished blocks on which a determined person may perch, provided that determination is not required elsewhere.
At the consultation, we asked for seats with backs. A representative explained that the open design encouraged movement. This was an elegant answer to a different question. We had asked how somebody might remain in the square without buying a drink or balancing on an object which appeared embarrassed to be furniture.
A bench is not a complete solution to loneliness, access or the decline of local shops. It is a place to sit. Its modesty is part of the argument for providing it. A person carrying shopping can rest; two friends can wait; someone arriving early need not turn waiting into a purchase.
There may be problems. Seats need maintaining, and some people may use them inconsiderately. Pavements also require maintenance, and we do not generally conclude that standing should therefore be discouraged. Public space means arranging for ordinary uses, not removing every feature around which difficulty might occur.
We have submitted a proposal for two benches near the edge, leaving the main route clear. I hope the next diagram includes them. Better still, I hope people can use them without first having to discover the designer’s preferred word for sitting down.
Text Two: The square after closing
An original account by a late-shift street cleaner.
I would welcome proper benches in the square. By ten at night, my legs would welcome them too. That does not make the discussion quite as simple as some of the letters suggest.
The polished blocks are awkward to clean around, and people leave cups beneath their edges. A bench could be easier in some ways. It would also become another object which somebody must wash, inspect and report when it breaks. These are not mysterious objections. They are the hours which arrive after the opening photograph.
I dislike hearing maintenance mentioned only when it can be used to stop a project. If the square is intended for people, work follows from people using it. The honest question is who will have the time and equipment, not whether we can design a place which never needs anyone to care for it.
What I ask is that the people who empty the bins and move the cleaning carts should be included before a final position is chosen. A good place in a drawing can be a difficult gap at midnight. A few inches can decide whether a machine passes or a person does the same patch on hands and knees.
Please put in the benches, and leave the access we need. I want a square in which an older shopper can rest in the afternoon and a cleaner can finish without an unnecessary struggle at night. Those should be parts of the same plan, rather than two reasons for different people to be disappointed.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about providing and maintaining public seating.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.