When the machine turned left
Text One: Questions instead of answers
An original account by a teacher mentoring a school robotics team.
The students began with a confident drawing. Their robot would travel across the competition area, collect three wooden blocks and place them inside a marked square. On paper, it completed the task without hesitation. The machine we built from that drawing moved forwards, paused and turned firmly towards a wall.
Six faces turned towards me. As the team mentor, I was expected to know what had gone wrong. I had several ideas, but I asked the students what they had observed. They looked disappointed. A teacher who replies to a question with another question can appear either wise or extremely unhelpful.
The team tested the robot again. This time, Arun noticed that one wheel began moving slightly later than the other. Sofia wanted to change the instructions controlling the whole route. Ben suggested checking the connection to the slower wheel first. Their discussion became more useful when they stopped trying to guess which answer I wanted.
The robot eventually crossed the area in a straight line. Collecting the blocks remained unreliable. One escaped from the machine, another was pushed beyond the marked square, and the third was collected successfully only when nobody was watching. Progress arrived in pieces too small for a celebration.
During the competition attempt, a connection came loose and the robot stopped. I could have reached across the barrier and pointed to it. Instead, the students used the checking routine they had written during practice. Ben found the loose connection, Sofia restarted the instructions and Arun watched the wheels. The robot collected two blocks before time ended.
We did not win. On the journey home, the students were already discussing how to improve the collecting mechanism. I had spent weeks resisting the temptation to make their machine work for them. Its imperfect performance showed that they no longer needed me to do so.
Text Two: Ours, even when it stopped
An original account by a student on a school robotics team.
Our first design looked convincing because nothing on the page had to move. We labelled each part, drew arrows to show the route and agreed that the difficult decisions had already been made. The finished robot corrected that belief by travelling directly towards the wall.
We asked our teacher what to change. She asked what we had noticed. At the time, this felt like avoiding the question. We knew the robot had turned left; we wanted the sentence that would make it stop doing so.
Repeating the test gave us more than repeating the complaint. Arun saw that the wheels did not begin together. I wanted to rewrite all the instructions, but Ben asked whether one connection was loose. Checking his smaller suggestion first saved us from changing parts that were already working. When the robot finally travelled straight, the movement seemed almost ordinary. We knew how many failed attempts it contained.
The collecting mechanism caused new problems. We adjusted it, tested it and filled a page with results. Some changes helped once and then failed. Our teacher continued to answer carefully without taking control. Gradually, her questions became less annoying because we had better answers for them.
At the competition, the robot stopped before reaching the first block. For a moment, I heard every other machine in the room. Then Ben began our checking routine. He found a loose connection, I restarted the instructions and Arun watched the wheels as the robot moved again. It collected only two blocks, but both were placed inside the square.
Another team received the trophy. I expected that to make our work feel smaller. Instead, I kept thinking about the moment when our teacher had known what might be wrong and had remained silent long enough for us to find it. The robot belonged to us because its successes had not been supplied to us. Its failures were ours too.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about preparing for and taking part in a school robotics competition.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.