The road out of town
Text One: Leaving was not the opposite
An original personal essay about moving away.
When I received the job offer, people asked whether I was excited to escape. I was excited. Escape was the part I was less sure about. It made the town sound like a room whose door had been locked, rather than a place in which I had been making a life.
There were reasons to leave. The work I wanted was elsewhere, and I liked the idea of streets on which nobody would immediately ask about my family. Being unknown seemed a kind of space. I could begin a conversation without a biography arriving ahead of me.
On my last Saturday, I walked to the small shop where I had bought notebooks since school. The owner asked whether my new flat had a decent table. It was a practical question which made the move suddenly more real than the repeated advice to make the most of my opportunities.
In the city, I enjoyed anonymity until I needed someone to tell me which shop would stay open late. Then I missed knowledge which I had mistaken for the town itself. I began acquiring new knowledge, slowly, without deciding that the old place had either failed me or deserved my permanent return.
I still come back. Sometimes I am impatient with a familiar conversation; sometimes it is exactly the one I wanted. Leaving has not made every part of home clearer. It has made me less willing to describe a complicated departure with a word which requires the place I left to have been a prison.
Text Two: The lives which stayed
An original article by a writer who remained in her hometown.
At school, the question about a promising student was where they would go. There were good reasons for it: courses, work and experiences not available nearby. The question became less helpful when going somewhere quietly became proof of having become someone.
I stayed. This was not a heroic decision to defend the town, nor evidence that I lacked imagination. I had work I wanted, people I loved and several ambitions which did not require a new postcode. Some were modest. Others were difficult enough without moving them to another city.
Friends who left sometimes apologise for missing a gathering as though I were guarding a gate through which they must ask permission to return. I am not. I am pleased to see them, and I am interested in what they have done. I would like the interest to travel in both directions.
A familiar address does not mean an unchanged life. Businesses close, neighbours arrive, friendships alter, and the person who meets a returning train is not simply an earlier version waiting beside the platform. Remaining can involve learning a place again while standing in streets whose names you already know.
I do not want fewer opportunities for young people to leave. I want staying to remain a choice which can contain movement of another kind. A town should be large enough in our descriptions to hold both the people who depart and the people whose lives do not need to be described as having been left behind.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about moving away from or remaining in a hometown.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.