Skip to content

Course home

Question bank·2.3 Section A: Reading
Sign up

2.3 Section A: Reading

EasyMediumHard
123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100
Question 71

Deciding what counts

Text One: The table after judging

An original account by a short-story competition judge.

The rules asked us to choose one winning story. They did not explain what to do when the three judges admired different things. On the final afternoon, the table was covered with marked copies, each carrying circles, arrows and comments which occasionally appeared to argue with one another across the paper.

We had agreed on criteria before reading. The stories should be controlled, engaging and suited to the word limit. These terms gave us a common language, but they did not turn reading into measurement. One judge praised an ending because it trusted the reader; another thought the same ending unfinished. Neither response could be dismissed as a failure to understand the criteria.

The eventual winner was not every judge’s first choice. It became the story we could all support after discussing its structure, its precise details and the confidence of its voice. Announcing a single title made the result appear much cleaner than the decision had been. The public saw a name and a position. It did not see the stories we returned to repeatedly or the sentences one judge defended long after the others were ready to move on.

This does not mean that the result was meaningless. Judging forced us to explain preferences which might otherwise have remained instinctive. It also required us to distinguish between a story we personally enjoyed and one we believed fulfilled the competition’s purpose most successfully. The distinction was not perfect, but making it improved the care with which we read.

A prize can bring attention to a piece of writing, but it cannot settle its value for every reader. Our decision recorded what three people thought after a particular discussion. It was a serious judgement, not a final fact about all the stories on the table.

Text Two: Second place in an envelope

An original personal account by a short-story competition entrant.

The envelope was thin enough to contain either excellent news or none. Inside, a printed letter told me that my story had been placed second. I read the sentence several times, pleased by the word ‘second’ and disappointed by everything it implied about ‘first’.

Until then, I had treated the competition as a way of making myself finish a story. Once the result arrived, that modest purpose disappeared. The placing seemed to have measured the story and found it one position short. I wanted to know whether the judges had disliked the opening, misunderstood the narrator or simply preferred somebody else’s subject.

A week later, the winning story was published. It was quieter than mine and left several questions unanswered. At first, I read those differences as instructions: perhaps successful stories should be quiet; perhaps explanations were a sign of weakness. Then I noticed how carefully the writer had prepared the unanswered questions. Copying the surface of that story would not reproduce the decisions underneath it.

The judges had included three comments on my entry. Two were complimentary, but the useful one concerned a conversation near the end. I had rushed it because the word limit was approaching. The comment did not tell me that the winning story was universally better. It identified a choice in my own writing which I could reconsider.

I still prefer winning to coming second. Pretending otherwise would turn disappointment into another kind of performance. But the number on the letter now seems less like a measurement and more like the record of one reading occasion. I have revised the conversation. I have not made the story quieter.

Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about what competition results can and cannot reveal about creative work.

Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.

[15]
Markscheme

2.3 Section A: Reading Questions

  1. IGCSE
  2. /English Language
  3. /2.3 Section A: Reading

324 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3 Section A: Reading, covering 2.3.5 AO1 in Section A, 2.3.6 AO2 in Section A, and 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.

More questions